China skirts questions in U.N. torture review - groups

GENEVA Mon Nov 10, 2008 9:44pm IST

Related Topics

GENEVA (Reuters) - Human rights groups expressed disappointment on Monday over what they saw as China's legalistic side-stepping of questions from the United Nations' torture watchdog on its interrogation and detention techniques.

Chinese ambassador Li Baodong told the U.N. Committee Against Torture in Geneva that his country expressly forbids torture and has introduced strict laws to punish all who intimidate, harrass and injure those in state custody.

But activists observing the review said that the 32-member Chinese delegation skirted questions about the prevalence of abuse in police stations, prisons, informal custody houses, psychiatric hospitals and other facilities.

"The Chinese delegation as a whole has not given data on enforcement, they have given data on the formal law," said Sharon Hom of the New York-based Human Rights In China.

Hom said that because Beijing classifies statistics about unusual deaths in prison and other criminal justice information as state secrets, it is nearly impossible for outsiders to know how extensive violations are.

"We cannot do an accurate, complete assessment if there is not accurate, transparent, reliable data," she told reporters after the two-day review ended. "However, what is on the table now is a very full list of important issues."

The Committee's 10 independent experts pressed China to reveal information about alleged cases of mistreatment of human rights lawyers, followers of Falun Gong spiritualism, drug addicts, and critics of the Beijing government.

They also sought details about China's crackdown in Tibet after demonstrations there in March, including reports that people died or were brutally attacked in Chinese custody.


Delegation leader Li rejected as "groundless and untrue" many allegations raised by Chinese and Western activist groups ahead of the review, dismissing them as "baseless information from organisations with ulterior motives".

"We have zero tolerance for torture," he told the panel, which monitors countries' compliance with the U.N. Convention Against Torture that China ratified in 1988.

"We have made large-scale judicial reforms to strictly regulate the law enforcement conduct of our judicial personnel."

Li defended the actions of Chinese police seeking to restore order in Tibet after demonstrations erupted there in March.

More than 1,200 people detained in the crackdown "have redeemed themselves and been released", Li said. "These released people are living a normal life and their rights are protected."

Some 69 Tibetans were jailed for arson, robbery, treason, troublemaking in the street, gathering to disrupt public order, offering information to people outside China, and other crimes, and eight are still being investigated, he said.

Rights groups say as many as 200 people were killed in the protests, and that far more people than acknowledged by Beijing were detained and subjected to "extreme brutality", with some forced to denounce the Dalai Lama as their spiritual leader.

"Not much sincerity was shown by China to give facts to the committee, especially on what is happening in Tibet," Ngawang Choephel of Tibetan U.N. Advocacy said after the Geneva session.

Under the U.N. convention, torture is defined as physical abuse or mental pain and suffering employed to force confessions from detainees or to discriminate against certain groups.

The Committee Against Torture will compile a report based on China's review, which will be published later this month.

Comments (0)
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.

  • Most Popular
  • Most Shared

Ukraine Crisis


Ferry Disaster

Ferry Disaster

Vice-principal of South Korea school in ferry disaster commits suicide.  Full Article 

 Marquez Dead

Marquez Dead

Nobel winner Garcia Marquez, master of magical realism, dies at 87.  Full Article 

Turkey Politics

Turkey Politics

Turkish president rules out role swap with Erdogan.  Full Article 

Mexico Earthquake

Mexico Earthquake

Powerful earthquake rattles Mexico, shakes buildings.  Full Article 

Missing Plane

Missing Plane

Drone risks damage at record depth in search for Malaysian plane.  Full Article 

Reuters India Mobile

Reuters India Mobile

Get the latest news on the go. Visit Reuters India on your mobile device.  Full Coverage