ANALYSIS - South Africa confounds Afro-pessimists

JOHANNESBURG Mon Jul 12, 2010 2:51pm IST

Ghana's goalkeeper Richard Kingson watches as the ball hits the back of his net after a goal by Germany's Mesut Ozil during their 2010 World Cup Group D soccer match at Soccer City stadium in Johannesburg June 23, 2010. REUTERS/Siphiwe Sibeko/Files

Ghana's goalkeeper Richard Kingson watches as the ball hits the back of his net after a goal by Germany's Mesut Ozil during their 2010 World Cup Group D soccer match at Soccer City stadium in Johannesburg June 23, 2010.

Credit: Reuters/Siphiwe Sibeko/Files

JOHANNESBURG (Reuters) - Rarely can a global event have generated so much advance pessimism as the World Cup.

The sceptics are now finally having to eat their words.

In the six years after South Africa won the right to stage the continent's first tournament, organisers endured a sea of negative reports and plenty of domestic self doubt.

There were persistent suggestions FIFA had a "Plan B" to move the soccer spectacular to Australia because of doubts over Africa's capacity for such a vast logistical exercise.

Other reports said the stadiums would not be ready in time, fans and teams would be victims of South Africa's frighteningly high rates of violent crime, that infrastructure would be incomplete and that transport would be a disaster.

With the exception of an embarrassing problem at Durban airport, where disorganisation prevented hundreds of irate fans landing to see the Spain-Germany semi-final, the country defied all these concerns.

Crime, the biggest bugbear, which did have an impact in reducing foreign visitors, has been virtually non-existent.

So it is no surprise that South Africa is now basking in a glow of satisfaction and unprecedented self-confidence.

Chief local organiser Danny Jordaan happily mocked the pessimists. "Just stand in the corner and sulk. You are a small minority. We will just leave you in the corner," he said.

President Jacob Zuma said the World Cup "has been a great success and will leave a lasting legacy in our country".

Jordaan believes the tournament was the most important national event since the end of apartheid in 1994. "It was a moment of special unity," he said at the weekend.

It undoubtedly has brought people together in a country still troubled by racial divisions, as a stream of ecstatic callers to radio stations testified.

"I have never experienced anything like this joyful multi-racial exuberance in my life. Even the inauguration of Nelson Mandela ... in 1994 pales into insignificance," said a letter to the Star newspaper from reader Farouk Laher.

It has also provided South Africa with a lasting legacy of roads, major infrastructure and especially transport to townships isolated under apartheid, which would probably not have been built for decades without the World Cup deadline.

Another major impact is the rebranding of Africa with a likely significant impact on investment and tourism.

"The long term impact is very important not just for South Africa but perhaps even more so for Africa," said Frans Cronje, deputy director of the South African Institute for Race Relations.

"Having hundreds of millions of people focused on South Africa, focused on the good bits, the stadiums, the football the infrastructure; they have seen it is not just a jungle out there but these guys have roads and highways and electricity."

Anne Fruhauf, an Africa analyst with Eurasia agreed. "The successful management of the World Cup should boost South Africa's global brand," she said. "A tournament well delivered will also help... the investment case for the wider African continent."

Independent analyst Nic Borain said the demonstration of racial unity had impressed both foreign journalists and fans. "This is an asset that is banked for the future," he said.

South African fund managers say new capital is already flowing to Africa on the back of the tournament.

GENERAL EUPHORIA

Despite the general euphoria, there are still critics who say South Africa should not have spent more than $5 billion on the tournament when it still has an army of poor and unemployed, the world's highest HIV caseload and myriad other problems.

Marcus Solomon, a social worker who spent a decade in the notorious Robben Island apartheid prison told Reuters: "They are spending so much money on one activity ... and the time is over for its use now and all that money is wasted."

But the critics have been muted in recent weeks.

Jack Lutaaya Kato, 22, a trader in Soweto township, complained he had made no money from the World Cup but added: "As Africans, we feel pride. In Europe, people did not know about South Africa. Now they have seen us in a good light."

When the World Cup circus moves on however, Zuma will face a major and possibly dangerous challenge -- can his squabbling government maintain the momentum?

"In the World Cup there was a large consensus. Everybody cooperated. It is absent when you look at the broader government or political landscape," said analyst Ebrahim Fakir of the Electoral Institute of South Africa.

"The glow of the tournament will fall away, government and policy people must be careful that they don't reap a bit of a whirlwind at the end of it... If you can build Soccer City on time, why can't you build an RDP (public project) house on time?" said Cronje.

"We have been able to prove ourselves in an extraordinary way ... we have done that for a month, why should it not be possible to do so on a more permanent basis," said High Court judge and law professor Dennis Davis.

(Additional reporting by Ed Cropley, Andrew Cawthorne, Diana Neille and Gugulakhe Lourie; Editing by Ossian Shine)

(For more news on Reuters India, click in.reuters.com)

Comments (0)
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.

  • Most Popular
  • Most Shared

CRICKET

Reuters Showcase

Legend On Board

Legend On Board

McGrath to train next generation of Indian pace bowlers.  Full Article 

Not Quitting Yet

Not Quitting Yet

Injured Australia captain Clarke rules out ODI retirement.  Full Article | Related Story 

Poor Form

Poor Form

Misbah going back to basics to solve batting slump.  Full Article 

Premier League

Premier League

Analysis: Premier League the biggest winner as talent pours in.  Full Article 

Manager Speaks

Manager Speaks

Foreign players can help England, says Hodgson.  Full Article 

Golf Update

Golf Update

Ryder Cup joy for veteran Westwood and rookie Gallacher.  Full Article 

Reuters India Mobile

Reuters India Mobile

Get the latest news on the go. Visit Reuters India on your mobile device.  Full Coverage