Multivitamins may not slow colon cancer

NEW YORK Thu Sep 9, 2010 8:57pm IST

Related Topics

NEW YORK (Reuters Health) - Taking a multivitamin is unlikely to help colon cancer patients in battling the disease, suggests a new study.

"There is widespread belief among cancer patients that taking multivitamins will help to treat their cancer and prolong life," lead researcher Dr. Kimmie Ng of the Dana-Farber Cancer Institute, in Boston, told Reuters Health in an e-mail.

Because 26 to 77 percent of cancer survivors report using the supplements, Ng and her colleagues wanted to see what impact, if any, these multivitamins really had on colon cancer recurrence and survival.

The team followed more than 1,000 individuals who had recently undergone surgery for advanced (stage III) colon cancer, which, combined with rectal cancer, is the third most diagnosed cancer in both men and women in the U.S.

About half of the patients reported multivitamin use during, and six months after, completion of their chemotherapy, report the researchers in the Journal of Oncology. (The study was partially funded by Pfizer, makers of a popular brand of multivitamins, as well as a colon cancer therapy.)

The study found no improved survival or extension of time to disease recurrence among those taking multivitamins compared to nonusers, even after adjusting for other relevant factors such as age and family history of cancer.

Of course, the finding doesn't rule out the possibility that certain vitamins might still be helpful in fighting off cancer. Some earlier studies have hinted at a protective effect from vitamin D, for instance, although at much higher doses than those found in standard multivitamins.

The 400 IU of vitamin D in multivitamins are unlikely to significantly increase levels of the vitamin's active form in the blood, noted Ng.

"This current study adds to a growing body of research that questions the purported benefit of multivitamin use," she said. "And it underscores the need to investigate the use of individual vitamins, such as vitamin D, which may, in fact, provide real benefit."

The results don't specifically address the question of whether vitamins can help to prevent cancers either, noted Ng.

Marian L. Neuhouser of Fred Hutchinson Cancer Research Center in Seattle led a recent Women's Health Initiative study that found no benefit of multivitamins in cancer prevention. She noted in an e-mail to Reuters Health that the take-home message from both studies is similar: "Multivitamins do not prevent cancer and they do not improve cancer prognosis."

However, Neuhouser added that the results from the new study can really only be applied to colon cancer patients.

Enthusiasm for multivitamins is nevertheless "dampened," said Ng, given her negative results on top of already conflicting evidence for the use of multivitamins in cancer prevention.

"So many patients ask their oncologists whether they should take multivitamins in conjunction with and after completion of cancer treatment, and I think we can now say to them that although it does not appear to be detrimental, we have not been able to show that multivitamins lead to decreased cancer recurrence and death," said Ng.

"Other dietary and lifestyle interventions that have shown promise in improving cancer outcomes include vitamin D, physical activity, and minimization of a Western dietary pattern," she added. "And further research on these factors is currently ongoing."

SOURCE: link.reuters.com/wak52p Journal of Clinical Oncology, online August 30, 2010.

FILED UNDER:
Comments (0)
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.

  • Most Popular
  • Most Shared

Health Alert

REUTERS SHOWCASE

Fighting AIDS

Fighting AIDS

'Bad' laws hurt sex workers, gays from Uganda to Nepal, AIDS meeting told.  Full Article 

Fitness Hooping

Fitness Hooping

Hoopsters put circus-inspired spin on cardio workout.  Full Article 

Information Vacuum

Information Vacuum

Sierra Leone religious leaders criticise government handling of Ebola.  Full Article 

Who's Responsible?

Who's Responsible?

U.S. CDC says it 'may never know' how bird flu mishap occurred.  Full Article 

HIV in India

HIV in India

Four of every 10 Asians living with HIV are Indian – U.N. report.  Full Article 

U.S. Medicare

U.S. Medicare

U.S. Medicare program scales back hospice drugs restrictions.  Full Article 

Medical Marijuana

Medical Marijuana

Illinois legalizes medical marijuana for children with seizures.  Full Article 

Reuters India Mobile

Reuters India Mobile

Get the latest news on the go. Visit Reuters India on your mobile device.  Full Coverage