ANALYSIS - Egypt's fate unclear as Mubarak's power crumbles

CAIRO Fri Feb 11, 2011 1:53am IST

People gather in Tahrir square, Cairo February 10, 2011. REUTERS/Asmaa Waguih

People gather in Tahrir square, Cairo February 10, 2011.

Credit: Reuters/Asmaa Waguih

Related Topics

CAIRO (Reuters) - A military coup? A triumph for people power? Egyptians watching as President Hosni Mubarak's 30-year rule disintegrated on Thursday could not be sure.

When a grim-faced military spokesman appeared on television to read "Communique No. 1" announcing that the army's higher council was in continuous session -- in Mubarak's conspicuous absence -- it looked like a classic military takeover.

Protesters in Cairo's Tahrir Square and elsewhere joyously celebrated reports of Mubarak's imminent departure, but for now decision-making appeared to have devolved to the military.

The Muslim Brotherhood, seen as Egypt's biggest organised opposition group, said it "looks like a military coup".

Hours later, uncertainty still remained over whether the army had taken over or Mubarak was still in power. Rumours flew that the 82-year-old leader would hand over to Omar Suleiman, his intelligence chief and newly appointed vice president.

"The fact that the army met without Mubarak who is the head of the armed forces means that the military has taken over power and I expect this to be announced shortly in Mubarak's televised speech," said Nabil Abdel Fattah, an analyst at Cairo's al-Ahram Center for Political and Strategic Studies.

"The army would then ask protesters to go home and in the coming period, it could decide to dissolve parliament and cancel the constitution, effectively making it the legislative authority," he said.


Abdel Fattah predicted a transitional government composed of military and civilian figures, with a cabinet headed by a younger prime minister "known for his competence and decency".

In Tunisia last month, former President Zine al-Abidine Ben Ali fled the country, apparently after army commanders refused to crush popular protests against his 23-year rule.

Rumours also swirled that Mubarak had left the country, despite his previous vows to "die on its soil".

"This is the height of confusion," said Hassan Abo Taleb, another analyst at the al-Ahram Center.

"It seems there are still negotiations going on between the army and the presidency. I think the army doesn't want to override the constitution, otherwise they would have clearly and openly announced that Mubarak was being pushed out."

He said chaos in Egypt was affecting the cohesion of the armed forces, whose leaders might consider three options.

The military could impose martial law, suspend the constitution and take power, warning protesters to leave Tahrir Square or face force. It could force Mubarak to transfer power to Suleiman. Or it could install a transitional government.

Any transition would be eased if Mubarak used his vast powers to institute constitutional changes before any handover of his prerogatives to Suleiman.

If the military takes over, there is no guarantee that it will ensure a transition to civilian rule, let alone democracy.

All of Egypt's four presidents since Gamal Abdel Nasser and the "Free Officers" toppled a British-backed monarchy in 1952 emerged from the military.

In recent Arab history, military coups have rarely been followed by a return to civilian rule -- although a Sudanese general followed that route after ousting former President Jaafar Nimeiri in 1985.

(Reporting by Yasmine Saleh and Dina Zayed)

Comments (0)
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.

  • Most Popular
  • Most Shared

Ebola Outbreak


Apple's Cook signals front line of new gay rights battle

Cook Speaks Up

Apple's Cook signals front line of new gay rights battle.  Full Article 

Gas Deal

Gas Deal

Ukraine, Russia, EU agree to natural gas supply deal.  Full Article 

Jerusalem Tensions

Jerusalem Tensions

Kerry urges restraint, expresses worry over tensions in Jerusalem.  Full Article 

Active Volcano

Active Volcano

National Guard arrives in Hawaii town threatened by lava.  Full Article 

Syria Crisis

Syria Crisis

U.S. defense chief will not discuss "critical" Syria memo .  Full Article 

Political Upheavel

Political Upheavel

Burkina president rejects opposition calls to step down after violence.  Full Article 

Reuters India Mobile

Reuters India Mobile

Get the latest news on the go. Visit Reuters India on your mobile device.  Full Coverage