PM Singh fails to dispel policy paralysis fears

NEW DELHI Wed Jun 29, 2011 4:41pm IST

Prime Minister Manmohan Singh speaks at a joint news conference during the BRICS (Brazil, Russia, India, China and South Africa) summit in Sanya, on the southern Chinese island of Hainan, April 14, 2011. REUTERS/Press Information Bureau of India/Handout/Files

Prime Minister Manmohan Singh speaks at a joint news conference during the BRICS (Brazil, Russia, India, China and South Africa) summit in Sanya, on the southern Chinese island of Hainan, April 14, 2011.

Credit: Reuters/Press Information Bureau of India/Handout/Files

Related Topics

NEW DELHI (Reuters) - India's cornered Prime Minister Manmohan Singh brushed aside on Wednesday widespread criticism that he was a "lame duck" leader presiding over a government mired in graft and policy paralysis, but offered little in way of policy steps he would take up.

The prime minister met five domestic media editors in an attempt to overhaul his reputation as out of touch with the country, with corruption scandals and stubbornly high inflation eroding confidence in his coalition government.

As the government fights the backlash from the scandals, investors are increasingly worried it will not push through reforms to support long-term growth in Asia's third largest economy, including an overhaul of its land acquisition policy, taxation system and foreign direct investment rules.

"I think the market will be looking for actions rather than comments," said Samiran Chakraborty, regional head of research at Standard Chartered Bank in Mumbai. "Confidence can come back only when there is perceptible movement in the policy stance. Before that, a cabinet reshuffle can bring in some hope."

Singh said, according to editors present at the meeting, that he was not leading a "puppet government" with the real power held by Congress party leader Sonia Gandhi and her advisers -- although that is a view widely held in India.

He denied speculation he would be replaced by Rahul Gandhi, the 41-year-old son of Sonia who has long been seen as a prime-minister in waiting, saying that was not on the party's agenda.

"He agreed that there was a perception (of crisis) but that the perception is wrong ... he is not a lame-duck prime minister," Kumar Ketkar, editor of Divya Marathi newspaper, told reporters after talks with Singh.

Analysts were unimpressed with the message from Wednesday's meeting, comparing it with Singh's last interaction with the media in February when the prime minister had voiced similar sentiments but ended up doing little to back them up.

Singh was critical of the media, calling it "accuser, prosecutor and judge" rolled into one. It was his third formal interaction with the media in his seven years in power.

The prime minister repeated that he would reshuffle his cabinet "soon" but declined to say whether there would be significant changes in top positions, according to two editors present at the meeting in the capital.

Singh has been criticised for not firing inefficient or graft-tainted ministers and his perceived inaction has taken off the sheen from his image as the economist who ushered in India's economic boom when he was finance minister in the 1990s.


Singh was again forced to discuss the issue of who would succeed him and whether it would happen soon.

A senior Congress party member and the interior minister have this month publicly praised Rahul Gandhi

as having the skills to be prime minister, hinting that Congress members were increasingly anxious to change leadership. Singh said he would be happy to make way for the young leader.

"I don't mind young leaders taking over ... but the question has not been put on the agenda or raised by the party," Singh said, according to editor Ketkar.

Singh's premiership has been besieged by graft scandals, including a $39 billion telecoms scam that saw former telecoms minister A. Raja arrested and parliament suspended by opposition protests.

Those scandals have been the focus of widely popular fasts by activists and the government's handling of the protests has added to the view it is out of touch with public sentiment.

"I'll be very blunt. The government has committed one blunder after the other," said N Bhaskara Rao, chairman of New Delhi-based think-tank Centre for Media Studies.

Congress was expected to push through a series of long-delayed economic reforms after winning a second term in office in 2009, but little progress has been made.

The government's inability to combat high inflation, exacerbated by fuel price rises this month, has led to widespread public anger, and damaged voter confidence in the ruling party with elections looming in 2014.

Economic growth is expected to slow down on high inflation and interest rates, with few expecting the government to be able to tame inflation, and fiscal deficit targets looking like an ambitious goal.

Three-quarters of India's leading companies have lost faith in the prime minister, and believe that a governance crisis and policy limbo will hit economic growth and their investment plans, a survey said this month.

Still foreign and domestic investors point out that the opportunities in India often outweigh the challenges, with its relatively untapped market with huge growth opportunities compared with those in struggling industrialised economies.

(Additional reporting by C.J. Kuncheria in New Delhi and Swati Bhat in Mumbai; Writing by Paul de Bendern; Editing by C.J. Kuncheria and Robert Birsel)

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see
Comments (2)
Ramamurthi wrote:
It was the same Manmohan as the finance minister who under the brilliant guidance of the then PM, Narasimha Rao, made an historic decision to liberate the economy from the clutches of government controls. It was a great departure from the conservative leftist ideology of the Nehru era. Since last 7 years, in his new avatar as PM, Manmohan,is sitting pretty on the tree, overseeing the corrupt animals in the corrupt congress UPA jungle,running a parralel black, economy,while the liberalization of the real economy continued to flourish. It is this which has helped the Indian economy to tide over international shocks and the rampant corruption in the government. Unfortunately, Manmohan seems helpless and unable to use his acumen to steer the country towards a progressive welfare state.

Jun 29, 2011 6:51pm IST  --  Report as abuse
Aarvi wrote:
The weakness is not identified by what the others say – but from his action. Unfortunately during the Past 7 years as PM,Mr MM Singh has not taken a single bold step. Every action was a meak reaction to what happened in the country. Had he been firm and pro active adn had he taken strong action to prove who is the boss, the country could have avoided entire scam – 2G, CWG, etc and the country could have saved the embarassment in the international arena. Even now, he could not speak or act firmly on any issue – the saving grace is he didn’t say ” I don’t know” ‘coalition compulsion’ etc. He should stand up like a man and behave like a PRIME MINISTER IN CHARGE OF THE COUNTRY instead of looking like a Student under ‘Internship’

Jun 29, 2011 9:12pm IST  --  Report as abuse
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.

  • Most Popular
  • Most Shared

Public Health


Cost Cutting

Cost Cutting

PM Modi boots officials out of the first class cabin.  Full Article 

Border Dispute

Border Dispute

China expresses concern about Indian plan to build border posts  Full Article 

Investment Campaigns

Investment Campaigns

More investor activism expected, but returns likely lower - survey.  Full Article 

Cook Speaks Out

Cook Speaks Out

Apple's Cook signals front line of new gay rights battle.  Full Article 

Ebola Outbreak

Ebola Outbreak

Individual genetic differences may affect Ebola survival - study.  Full Article 

Formula One

Formula One

Mercedes rivals warm up with burgers and bling.  Full Article 

Reuters India Mobile

Reuters India Mobile

Get the latest news on the go. Visit Reuters India on your mobile device.  Full Coverage