COLUMN - A tale of two countries: David Cay Johnston

Fri Aug 12, 2011 6:48pm IST

A Chinese 100 yuan banknote is placed under a $100 banknote (top) in this photo illustration taken in Beijing in this November 7, 2010 file photo. REUTERS/Petar Kujundzic/Files

A Chinese 100 yuan banknote is placed under a $100 banknote (top) in this photo illustration taken in Beijing in this November 7, 2010 file photo.

Credit: Reuters/Petar Kujundzic/Files

Related Topics

The author is a Reuters columnist. The opinions expressed are his own.

By David Cay Johnston

MACAU (Reuters) - In China it is among the best of times, in America it is among the worst of times, the age of wisdom in one country, the age of foolishness in the other when it comes to taxes and economic growth.

Here is some news about the idea that the path to prosperity is paved with lower taxes and reduced government spending.

In China, tax revenues since 2003 have grown a fifth faster than the booming economy.

In America, tax revenues are growing a quarter slower than the sputtering economy.

The result is that tax revenues are up 22 percent as a share of the Chinese economy, but down 7 percent as a share of the American economy.

In China, jobs are everywhere. In America, joblessness is everywhere.

There is a lesson here and it goes to the heart of why America, stuck for a decade in the economic doldrums, risks foundering on the shoals of economic ruin not because it taxes too much, but because it has adopted unsound and profoundly anti-market economic rules while Communist-led China sails into the future ever more prosperous even though its tax burdens are rising.

While China sees growth and taxes as circulatory economics each needing the other, America imagines taxes as bleeding the economy.


What the Chinese grasp is that it matters where tax money is spent. So they spend it on education, infrastructure and pensions to get older workers out and younger ones in.

In urban China -- where half the people live -- wide, smooth roads mark the land, the stretch marks of a growing economy. Storm sewers are being built to deal with chronic flooding along the low-lying coast and electric generating plants are coming on line as fast as the now ubiquitous air conditioners that make life in this humid region pleasant.

In America, a drive is on to cut teacher pay while potholes ensure brisk business for alignment, shock absorber and tire shops and people whose guaranteed pensions were replaced with 401(k) plans learn the meaning of a 201(k).

What the Chinese know, and Americans have forgotten, is this: all private wealth is built on a foundation of commonwealth. And that commonwealth is financed with taxes.

Build skyscrapers on a foundation of sand and they will eventually fall over, wiping out investments and causing lasting damage to those hit by the debris.

But build on a foundation of granite as the Chinese are doing and the sky is the limit, even when the economy is constrained by Communist Party minders and a host of laws that dampen the human desire to be free.


The hard facts are these:

Since 2003, China's tax revenue has grown a fifth faster than its gross domestic product. The Chinese economy grew at a 16.6 percent compound annual rate over those seven years while tax revenues grew at a hair under 20 percent.

During those same years in America the economy grew at a compound annual growth rate of just under 4 percent while taxes grew at just 2.8 percent.

Neither the Chinese nor American figures are adjusted for inflation, as is the norm in this column, because it is the relative growth of taxes and the economy that matters. And the relative and relevant facts are that as taxes become a growing share of the Chinese economy it keeps growing, while as taxes become a shrinking share of the U.S. economy it sputters along.

The Chinese are so confident of their economic growth that they just cut individual income taxes by removing 60 million low-income workers from the income tax rolls and lowering rates on the 24 million workers still on the tax rolls.

Contrast this with the United States, where the Tea Party wants to raise taxes on the lowest income Americans, adding to the 2011 tax increase that President Obama acquiesced to last December on every working American who earns less than $20,000 ($40,000 for married couples).

Unlike the Tea Partiers, the Chinese get the ancient, time-tested and therefore (in the classic meaning of the word) profoundly conservative idea that the greater your economic gain the greater your tax burden. They also grasp the teachings of Adam Smith that taxing the incomes of the poor just raises the general labor price level and of John Locke that there is no tax to be had from the poor.

But as Charles Dickens taught us long ago this is the season of light, the season of darkness; the spring of hope, the winter of despair; we have everything before us, we have nothing before us; we are all going direct to heaven, we were all going direct the other way. In short, the period of the Tale of Two Cities was like the present period between China and America.

(Editing by Howard Goller)

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see
Comments (4)
BlamBlam wrote:
We will never make it. A country without countrymen, that’s what we are

Aug 12, 2011 4:26am IST  --  Report as abuse
TomTheSeal wrote:
The U.S.A. is the “SECRET” to China’s “success”, not to mention currency manipulation, trademark and patent and copyright violations, and, lest we forget to mention that China taxes imports to China from America at 25%, while America taxes imports from China into America at only 3%.

Then, there’s William Jefferson Clinton, who dained it his right to give America’s missle technology, technology bought and paid for by American taxpayers, to China.

Well, there you have it ! China’s “SECRETS” to success !

Aug 12, 2011 5:58am IST  --  Report as abuse
idealist2 wrote:
Why does this article miss the obvious ??? China manipulates their exchange rate and makes their currency very cheap, so no one can compete against them. If you make your currency almost worthless, sure your products look cheap. This is not rocket science. This issue is obvious to millions of Americans, but our bought and paid Congress does nothing.

Aug 13, 2011 6:27pm IST  --  Report as abuse
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.

  • Most Popular
  • Most Shared

Shares Hit Record

Sensex, Nifty rise to second consecutive record high

Sensex surges 500 points on BOJ easing, L&T gains

The BSE Sensex and Nifty surged to record highs for a second consecutive session on Friday after Bank of Japan's surprise expansion of its massive stimulus programme raised hopes for additional foreign inflows, boosting blue-chips such as Larsen & Toubro.  Full Article 


Wilful Negligence?

Wilful Negligence?

SEBI piles pressure on Sahara to sell overseas hotels  Full Article 

Indian Economy

Indian Economy

India's fiscal deficit in H1 almost 83 pct of full-year target.  Full Article 

M&M Earnings

M&M Earnings

M&M Q2 net profit down 4 percent, hit by poor monsoon.  Full Article 

Ban on E-Cigs?

Ban on E-Cigs?

Govt considers ban on e-cigarettes, sale of single smokes.  Full Article 



Silver futures in India hit four-year low on global cues.  Full Article 

BOJ Policy

BOJ Policy

BOJ shocks markets with surprise easing as inflation slows.  Full Article 

Shadow Banking

Shadow Banking

China's shadow banking sector growing rapidly, third largest in world - FSB.  Full Article 

Reuters India Mobile

Reuters India Mobile

Get the latest news on the go. Visit Reuters India on your mobile device  Full Coverage