Government seeks compromise with Hazare

NEW DELHI Wed Aug 24, 2011 1:39am IST

Supporters of veteran social activist Anna Hazare shout slogans as they wave national flags on the seventh day of Hazare's fast at Ramlila grounds in New Delhi August 22, 2011. REUTERS/Adnan Abidi

Supporters of veteran social activist Anna Hazare shout slogans as they wave national flags on the seventh day of Hazare's fast at Ramlila grounds in New Delhi August 22, 2011.

Credit: Reuters/Adnan Abidi

Related Topics

NEW DELHI (Reuters) - Government on Tuesday stepped up efforts to end national anti-corruption protests led by an ailing 74-year-old social activist as he entered a second week of fasting, but the first meetings to broker a truce ended without a breakthrough.

Top ministers from the ruling Congress party, under fire from the biggest social protests in decades, met aides of activist Anna Hazare in the capital in the late evening to try to end the impasse over implementing tougher anti-graft laws.

Prime Minister Manmohan Singh wrote a personal letter to Hazare asking him to end his hunger strike amid growing concerns over the self-styled Gandhian activist's health, and called a meeting of political party leaders for Wednesday.

Hazare has lost nearly six kgs since he began his fast to demand a bill to create an autonomous anti-corruption agency, a campaign that has drawn support mainly from the middle class against Singh's government.

"The dialogue will continue and I am hopeful we will be able to work out a solution," said Finance Minister Pranab Mukherjee, one of the country's most experienced and powerful politicians, who was part of the talks.

"Considerable progress made in talks with government," Kiran Bedi, a top Hazare aide, wrote on Twitter, though she told reporters Hazare would not stop fasting without a written

commitment from the government to accept his demands.

Hazare's protest prompted the government to introduce the bill into parliament in August, though his supporters have slammed the existing draft as toothless.

"Over the last few days, I have watched with increasing concern the state of your health," Singh wrote in his letter.

"At worst, our paths and methodologies may differ, though I do believe that even those differences have been exaggerated."

The bill is now parked with a parliamentary standing committee. The protesters want the government's draft bill withdrawn and their own version passed by the end of the month,

a demand which senior government figures say is unrealistic.

But in another attempt at compromise, Singh also said in the letter that Hazare's version of the bill could also be discussed in parliament.

Speaking to supporters after the talks, Hazare's aides said the government was prepared to yield to a key demand to include the prime minister in the ombudsman's ambit, though sticking points remained on other issues. No government official confirmed the protesters' statements.

Hazare remained lying or sitting on a public stage on open ground in the capital New Delhi for much of the day, surrounded by at least 10,000 supporters in the monsoon heat where open toilets and spilling waste were starting to cause outbreaks of food poisoning and illness.

His doctors have fretted about Hazare's worsening condition after the activist declined their advice to go to hospital or take medicine.

"Who is scared of sacrificing their life?" Hazare told his followers on Tuesday night, to loud cheers. "I am not. That is what my conscience is telling me."

With key state elections next year that pave the way for a 2014 general election, the government must end a crisis that has paralysed policy making and parliament and added to Singh's unpopularity amid high inflation and corruption scams.

Many of India's middle class, the fastest growing population segment, have joined forces with Hazare to protest a system that requires bribes for everything from driver's licences to birth certificates and a series of graft scandals that have touched top politicians and businessmen in Asia's third largest economy.

By mid-afternoon on Tuesday, thousands had gathered in the muddy, water-logged protest ground in Delhi. As a popular actor led songs and chants on a stage, a large number of students were walking in a procession, or passing by in trucks, shouting anti-government slogans.

"People should continue with this struggle even if I'm not there," Hazare said. "This is our second freedom struggle."

Hazare, who has carried out scores of hunger strikes over the last few decades to pressure governments, has been visited by Hindu gurus, former judges and Bollywood actors. But he has refused to have any politicians on his stage.

His deteriorating health could force the government to decide whether to force feed him -- a move that could spark further protests against a fumbling government of elderly ministers widely seen as out of touch.

A group of leftist and regional party members staged a sit in at parliament on Tuesday, one of two opposition protests against the government this week. The main Hindu nationalist

opposition Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) is organising a nationwide protest against the government on Thursday.

Criticism of Hazare's hunger strike has also surfaced from activists and academics who say it is setting a bad precedent by holding democratic institutions hostage with his uncompromising stand. There have been criticisms from Muslim groups that he is too close to radical Hindu groups.

Hazare was briefly jailed last Tuesday, a move the government tried to reverse quietly. But he refused to leave prison until the government allowed him to continue his vigil, in public, for 15 days. He was released on Friday.

Several scandals, including a telecoms bribery scam that may have cost the government up to $39 billion, led to Hazare demanding anti-corruption measures.

(Additional reporting by Alistair Scrutton, Manoj Kumar, Nigam Prusty, Abhijit Neogy and Annie Banerji, editing by Tim Pearce)

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see
Comments (2)
PritisMajumdar wrote:
The present govt. of India and its caucus are trying to defuse the Anna’s non-violent movement against endless corruption prevailing all levels of govt. right from ministers, civil servants to lowest employees except a few who run the show with no appropriate reward. The all party meeting, standing committee etc are the process of delaying the anti-graft movement to divert the issue. The members of the standing committee appear to be a laughing stock. The congress party took years after years to make Lok Pal bill and killed a several decades. Nothing concrete step could be taken by this party while in power for a major periods since 1947 15th August till now. So, enough is enough. No help from people like Aruna Roy and Arundhoti Roy is required as they are the agent of a particular family members from whom they may eager to get some vested personal interest.

Aug 23, 2011 5:33pm IST  --  Report as abuse
PBALA46 wrote:
I think the initiative to break the ice is welcome. The issue is of political nature in as much as the big question is whose voice must be heard, affected people or law makers, thanedar or tormented people. The Government of the day led by the team of lawyers vitiated the atmosphere and played out all tricks in their bag and used the likes of Tiwaris to discredit Anna and his movement by treating him and his movement purely a law and order issue which they can suppress as they did with Ram Dev or worst still late Jay Prakash. Not before attempted smear campaign started producing negative impact on Government.
Anna and his team showed remarkable flexibility in climbing down from their ‘high horses’, but Government is still hastening slow in responding to the core of people’s demand expressed in the surge of reactions, and in solidarity with Anna and his Team. They may not be literate, well informed about nuances of constitutional implications of PM or Judiciary being included or excluded but they bear the brunt of the corrupt patwari or police beat constable on the prowl exploiting their uniform or demonstrating extra sensitivity to stuff their pockets.
Let us hope PM will take the lead in getting the nation out of the logjam of its own creation, statesmen like, not letting Police Commissioner to yet again try Ram Dev treatment or pre-dawn swoop in a ‘preventive coup’ and send packing ‘whistle blower’ Anna to the den of under-trial criminals.

Aug 23, 2011 6:50pm IST  --  Report as abuse
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.

  • Most Popular
  • Most Shared

Maritime Piracy


Ban On E-cigarettes

Ban On E-cigarettes

Govt considers ban on e-cigarettes, sale of single smokes  Full Article 

 SpaceShipTwo Crash

SpaceShipTwo Crash

Test flight of Virgin Galactic spaceship ends in fatal crash in California.  Full Article 

Ukraine Crisis

Ukraine Crisis

Europe won't recognise vote in eastern Ukraine, Merkel tells Putin.  Full Article 

ATP World Rankings

ATP World Rankings

Federer's number one hopes take a hit in Paris defeat.  Full Article 

Sahara Troubles

Sahara Troubles

SEBI piles pressure on Sahara to sell overseas hotels.  Full Article 

Myanmar's Peace Talks

Myanmar's Peace Talks

Myanmar's leaders seek to revive peace talks, maintain reforms   Full Article 

A Minute With

A Minute With

Bollywood's Kalki Koechlin on playing disabled teen.  Full Article 

Formula One

Formula One

Hamilton fastest as Mercedes dominate U.S. practice.  Full Article 

Reuters India Mobile

Reuters India Mobile

Get the latest news on the go. Visit Reuters India on your mobile device.  Full Coverage