BREAKINGVIEWS - James Murdoch weaker after UK phone-hack grilling

Thu Nov 10, 2011 11:38pm IST

BSkyB Chairman James Murdoch appears before a parliamentary committee on phone hacking at Portcullis House in London July 19, 2011. REUTERS/Parbul TV via Reuters Tv

BSkyB Chairman James Murdoch appears before a parliamentary committee on phone hacking at Portcullis House in London July 19, 2011.

Credit: Reuters/Parbul TV via Reuters Tv

Related Topics

(The author is a Reuters Breakingviews columnist. The opinions expressed are his own)

By Chris Hughes

LONDON (Reuters Breakingviews) - James Murdoch got slapped around in his latest scrape in the UK phone-hacking scandal. A grilling by lawmakers failed to land a knock-out blow on the News Corp scion, who was inappropriately likened to a Mafia boss. But the hearings still left him weakened, and make it harder for him to be effective in his role as BSkyB chairman.

The second bout of questioning came after Murdoch's earlier testimony was challenged by two former News Corp executives at the centre of the voicemail interception scandal at the now defunct News of the World tabloid. But Murdoch's stance on the disputed issue -- that evidence of widespread phone hacking wasn't explicitly laid before him in 2008 -- still lacks any decisive challenge.

The doesn't mean Murdoch was vindicated. He did concede that he was made aware of the existence of an email containing evidence of endemic phone hacking -- only without being told its full significance. This is a change on his earlier testimony, which undermines his claims that he had given consistent evidence when other witnesses have flip-flopped.

Moreover, Murdoch was bounced into saying he might allow his two accusers access to their old computers, to help them clarify their testimony. It's hard to see how Murdoch can now stop this. Who knows what that might uncover.

Whatever Murdoch knew, he failed to grab the whole issue by the scruff of the neck. At best, he comes across as a busy executive fixated on News Corp's more glamorous TV empire and out of touch with UK current affairs. But even then, there are several instances of management incompetence. Murdoch didn't, for example, ask enough questions about why a big civil settlement was being offered to a hacking victim.

The hearing on Nov. 10 won't topple Murdoch from News Corp or BSkyB overnight. But the story looks set to be a distraction for longer. Murdoch's competence has been shown to be wanting. His fellow directors at BSkyB have more reason to doubt he should lead the board.

(Editing by Hugo Dixon and Sarah Bailey)

FILED UNDER:
Comments (0)
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.

  • Most Popular
  • Most Shared

REUTERS SHOWCASE

RBI Policy Review

RBI Policy Review

RBI keeps rates on hold, warns on inflation  Full Article 

Monsoon Season

Monsoon Season

India's 2014 monsoon ends with double-digit rain deficit .  Full Article 

Cleanliness Drive

Cleanliness Drive

Modi orders officials to clean loos on Gandhi's birthday.  Full Article 

Bid to Boost Trading

Bid to Boost Trading

RBI takes small steps to deepen markets.  Full Article 

Car Recall

Car Recall

Maruti Suzuki says to recall 69,555 cars.  Full Article 

China Factory Data

China Factory Data

China final HSBC PMI steady in September on stronger global demand but risks remain  Full Article 

Oil Demand

Oil Demand

India's thirst for oil grows even as China cuts back  Video 

EBay Divests PayPal

EBay Divests PayPal

EBay to spinoff PayPal in 2015  Full Article 

New 'Windows'

New 'Windows'

Microsoft names next operating system 'Windows 10'.  Full Article 

Reuters India Mobile

Reuters India Mobile

Get the latest news on the go. Visit Reuters India on your mobile device.  Full Coverage