BREAKINGVIEWS: Too-coy India prompts Citi's HDFC retreat

MUMBAI Fri Feb 24, 2012 3:48pm IST

Picture showing HDFC's head office. Taken from official website.

Picture showing HDFC's head office. Taken from official website.

Related Topics

Stocks

   

MUMBAI (Reuters Breakingviews) - You should be careful what you wish for. India has resisted, strongly, what it sees as excessive foreign participation in its banking system. And with the need to conserve capital at home, it's no real surprise that Citi(C.N) has decided to cash in its 9.9 percent stake in Housing Development Finance Corp(HDFC.NS) for $2 billion. But had India allowed Citi more skin in the game it might have stuck around.

India's banking regulator has long worried about hot money and fair-weather friends. But the protectionism deployed actually increases the dangers. With a 10 percent cap on foreign direct investment in Indian banks, Citi lacked a real say in how HDFC was managed.

Other Indian banks have significant foreign shareholdings, but they are all in small chunks which, like Citi's, are relatively easy to exit. HSBC (HSBA.L) owns 9.2 percent of Axis Bank (AXBK.NS), India's third largest private sector bank. Deutsche (DBKGn.DE) owns about 10 percent of ICICI (ICBK.NS). And HSBC and Rabo both have 4.8 percent stakes in Yes Bank (YESB.NS).

Foreign banks are also allowed to set up their own branches and subsidiaries in India but their growth is restricted by a strict cap on the number of new branches they can open. India clearly wants the best of both world's -- enough foreign capital to get the benefits of investment and competition, but not too much so that the system becomes dominated by foreign banks. The regulator published proposals last year which would allow foreign banks more branches if they converting existing branches into local subsidiaries. This would come with a rider that the total capital of foreign banks could not exceed 25 percent of the capital in the system.

These plans came over a year ago. Since then nothing. It's a further sign of the paralysis that has struck Indian governance. Citi's exit is a wake-up call, a helpful reminder of work still to be done rebalancing the Indian banking system.

CONTEXT NEWS

-- Citigroup has raised $1.9 billion selling its entire stake in HDFC at 657.50 rupees a share, Reuters reported on February 24. The transaction is the largest share sale in India this year. (Read main story: Citigroup sells entire stake in HDFC, click here)

-- Although Indian banks can have up to 74 percent of aggregate foreign investment, no single investor is permitted to control more than 10 percent of the bank without the permission of the Reserve Bank of India.

(The author is a Reuters Breakingviews columnist. The opinions expressed are his own)

(Editing by Robert Cole and David Evans)

FILED UNDER:
Comments (0)
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.

  • Most Popular
  • Most Shared

REUTERS SHOWCASE

Monetary Policy

Monetary Policy

Fed renews zero rate pledge, but hints at steeper rate hike path.  Full Article 

Eyeing Stocks

Eyeing Stocks

Interview - EPFO chief urges green light to buy stocks  Full Article 

Stimulus Reports

Stimulus Reports

China cenbank injects $81 bln into major banks to support economy - reports  Full Article 

Ranbaxy Investigation

Ranbaxy Investigation

Ranbaxy says U.S. authorities seek information on pricing data.  Full Article 

E-Commerce

E-Commerce

Tiger Global leads $60 million investment in Quikr.  Full Article 

Monsoon Update

Monsoon Update

Delayed retreat of monsoon rains to start this weekend  Full Article 

Financing Deal

Financing Deal

IndiGo agrees $2.6 billion aircraft finance deal with China's ICBC  Full Article 

Grim Outlook

Grim Outlook

Sony deepens loss estimate on struggling smartphone business  Full Article 

Reuters India Mobile

Reuters India Mobile

Get the latest news on the go. Visit Reuters India on your mobile device.  Full Coverage