Key political risks to watch in India

NEW DELHI Thu Mar 1, 2012 5:14pm IST

A girl walks in front of the portraits of Congress party leader Sonia Gandhi (L), her son and Member of Parliament, Rahul Gandhi (C) and Prime Minister Manmohan Singh in Kochi, March 7, 2009. REUTERS/Sivaram V./Files

A girl walks in front of the portraits of Congress party leader Sonia Gandhi (L), her son and Member of Parliament, Rahul Gandhi (C) and Prime Minister Manmohan Singh in Kochi, March 7, 2009.

Credit: Reuters/Sivaram V./Files

Related Topics

Stocks

   

NEW DELHI (Reuters) - India's weak economy is exposed to an extended euro zone crisis, the coalition government is under great strain, and a massive corruption scandal is raising the still unlikely scenario of Prime Minister Manmohan Singh's second term being cut short before a general election due in 2014.

State election results in early March could put Singh's Congress party under severe pressure.

RATINGS (Unchanged since February unless stated):

S&P: BBB-

MOODY'S: Baa3

FITCH: BBB-

The cost of insuring against default on 5-year sovereign debt traded around 85 basis points at the start of February, down 20 points from the start of the year.

Following is a summary of key political risks in India:

ECONOMIC MALAISE

A feel good rally in Indian markets has given welcome relief to investors after months of gloom that made the currency and the stock market among the world's worst performing last year, but under the surface the problems afflicting Asia's third-largest economy remain largely unabated and unaddressed.

Inflation is down sharply, but almost entirely because of a drop in volatile food prices. And with the government embroiled in political wrangling over corruption scandals and unreliable coalition partners the prospects seem slim for tricky tax reform or a softening of foreign investment rules that could help deal with infrastructure bottlenecks.

An early-2012 Supreme Court order that 122 telecoms licences be revoked was deeply embarrassing for the government, and the winter session of parliament was an unmitigated disaster from start to finish.

As a result of passing no major legislation, the government now has a heavy load of promised reforms to try and push through two fractious houses in the budget session in March. Fickle coalition partners and a disruptive opposition mean the government is often effectively a minority when it tables bills.

Prime Minister Singh promises to bring in a stalled policy to allow foreign supermarkets into India, along with a corruption ombudsman. The first stage of a new tax system is planned for April. On current form, nobody should hold their breath.

In December, Goldman Sachs' Jim O'Neill called India the most disappointing of the BRICS countries, and warned of a risk of a balance of payments crisis if policymakers were not careful.

Asia's No. 3 economy is sitting on a comfortable cushion of $300 billion in foreign reserves and a confidence-building $15 billion currency swap line with Japan was unveiled in December, so comparisons with India's 1991 payments crisis are premature.

But as ever, India's dependence on imported, then subsidized energy is a weakness, with high prices adding to pressure both on the current account and fiscal deficits. A drawn out crisis in Europe could exacerbate the capital outflows and further moderate exports.

Morgan Stanley wrote in February that the ongoing fiscal and current account deficits will continue to pressure the rupee against the dollar over the long term.

"As the economy undergoes an extensive deleveraging process, we expect Indian equities and credits to underperform against their regional and emerging market peers during 2012," it said.

What to watch:

-- Budget on March 16. The market is asking for fiscal consolidation and there may be some rollback of subsidies, but the government's political priorities mean it will struggle to significantly cut spending going forward.

-- Headline inflation. If price rises show a sustained slowdown, expect the monetary easing India Inc. has been demanding for months.

-- Moves to accelerate project approvals and implementation.

-- The global economy and domestic demand.

ELECTIONS AND POLITICAL WRANGLING

Elections in five states will test support for the ruling Congress party roughly half way through Singh's second term. Elections are hard to predict in India, but opinion polls suggest Congress could do better than a year of corruption scandals and disappointing growth would suggest.

A poor result for Congress would compound the feeling that Singh is a lame-duck. Already, and even from within the ruling Congress party, anger at Singh's lacklustre performance is rising, with growing talk in the Indian media that he could step aside this year to be replaced by a caretaker until elections.

That is still unlikely and the government could probably also muster the support to survive a no-confidence vote. The government's real saving grace may be the lack of appetite in the opposition Bharatiya Janata Party for an general election before 2014. Despite Singh's woes, it is by no means clear the BJP has won over many voters to its Hindu nationalist cause.

The party could win in farming state Punjab, and in the 200 million people strong Uttar Pradesh, any improvement on the 22 seats it currently holds in the 403 seat state assembly would be spun as a victory.

Rahul Gandhi, son of current party leader Sonia Gandhi, has staked his political reputation on getting a good result in Uttar Pradesh, which may be a barometer for the national mood ahead of general elections in 2014.

Even if the party comes in fourth place but forms a coalition government in the state he will be seen as a success.

Party chief Sonia Gandhi, who is at least as influential as the prime minister, has made more public appearances but has shed no light on the illness she is suffering, which some Indian media reports say is cancer.

What to watch:

-- The Gandhi dynasty. Rahul Gandhi has yet to prove himself as an effective politician, raising concerns he will struggle to lead the party if his mother steps down.

-- Election results, which will be announced on March 6.

-- Political wrangling around the budget for the 2012/13 fiscal year, likely to be announced after the state election results in early March.

BETWEEN CHINA AND PAKISTAN

India's foreign policy focus used to be first Pakistan, then China. Now it is more China, then Pakistan. Relations with Islamabad have improved considerably in recent months, with an upgrading of trade ties and an easing of visa regulations helping the thaw.

Still, it would only take one armed attack in India bearing the hallmarks of Pakistani-based militants to reverse the advances. Partly in response to its worries about China's steadily increasing influence among all its neighbours, not least Pakistan, India has forged closer ties with the United States, Australia, Japan and Vietnam.

Pakistan's own perilous political situation could have far reaching fallout for relations between the nuclear armed neighbours.

This jostling between China and India is not necessarily dangerous and the risks are offset by growing trade and economic relations, but the rivalry will dominate India's policy decisions for years to come.

India is spending heavily on arms to keep pace with China's growing military might, and the two countries still have unresolved border issues. India is also stepping up its involvement in Afghanistan, possibly at the behest of Washington, worried about a power vacuum as NATO troops withdraw in the next few years.

What to watch:

-- Development of ties with East Asian nations to counter China, not least in the South China Sea. Australia has mentioned the possibility of a tri-lateral security pact with India and the United States. India says this is not on the cards but is stepping up naval cooperation with Australia.

-- Pakistan's domestic problems. The fall of the civilian government there could undo the progress made on normalising ties in the past year.

(Editing by Daniel Magnowski)

FILED UNDER:
Comments (0)
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.

  • Most Popular
  • Most Shared

REUTERS EXCLUSIVE

REUTERS SHOWCASE

iOS 8 Issue

iOS 8 Issue

iOS 8 causing Bluetooth connectivity issues - Apple news blog  Full Article 

Modi In U.S.

Modi In U.S.

Obama, Modi work to deepen improving U.S.-India ties  Full Article | Full Coverage 

NYT Job Cut

NYT Job Cut

New York Times to cut jobs as new products disappoint  Full Article 

Factory Activity

Factory Activity

Factories expand at slowest pace this year in September  Full Article 

Monetary Policy

Monetary Policy

RBI not biased towards either raising or cutting rates - Rajan  Full Article 

Weak Demand

Weak Demand

Weak demand hits factory activity across Asia, Europe  Full Article 

Pimco Fund

Pimco Fund

Pimco Total Return Fund posts record $23.5 bln net outflow in Sept  Full Article 

Hopeful of Profit

Hopeful of Profit

GM sees first European profit in 2016 after years of losses  Full Article 

Reuters India Mobile

Reuters India Mobile

Get the latest news on the go. Visit Reuters India on your mobile device.  Full Coverage