BRICS interests differ over joint bank, says Zoellick

BHITARKANIKA SANCTUARY, Orissa Thu Mar 29, 2012 5:34pm IST

1 of 2. World Bank President Robert Zoellick smiles as he crosses the river Bhitarkanika in a ferry to visit the Integrated Coastal Zone Management Project and Orissa Rural Livelihoods Project at Gupti village in Orissa March 28, 2012.

Credit: Reuters/Parivartan Sharma

BHITARKANIKA SANCTUARY, Orissa (Reuters) - A plan to form a joint development bank by the BRICS group of the world's most powerful emerging economies will have a hard time getting off the ground and could struggle to match the World Bank's expertise, World Bank President Robert Zoellick said.

Deflecting criticism that the World Bank is too dominated by the United States, Zoellick said it had changed dramatically in his term, with a managing team now made up of many more figures from the emerging world.

Leaders from Brazil, Russia, India, China and South Africa were meeting in New Delhi on Thursday to outline plans for a new bank which will help fund infrastructure and act as alternative lender to the World Bank and other finance bodies.

Zoellick told Reuters in an interview late on Wednesday that there are already a series of regional development banks and many countries have their own such banks, but if a BRICS bank was formed, the World Bank would work closely with it.

"I think the interests of India may be more in terms of bringing capital in, the interests of China may be more in terms of internationalising the Renminbi. I think Russia is a little uncertain and Brazil has a very big development bank," he said.

"The World Bank works with private sector funders, development banks, regional banks and we'd work with a BRICS bank, but it would probably be difficult for it to replicate the knowledge and expertise that we fund."

Zoellick, who was visiting a bank-funded coastal conservation project in east India's Orissa state, told reporters later that setting up a new bank was "a complicated venture" which would present challenges such as getting capital and a good rating from international financial agencies.

The head of the global money lender is ending his five-year term in June and the job is now one of the most hotly contested, with a U.S. candidate for the first time being challenged by two contenders from the developing world.

Under a so-called "gentleman's agreement" between the U.S. and Europe, Washington has claimed the top post at the World Bank since its founding after World War Two, while a European has always led the International Monetary Fund (IMF), its sister Bretton Woods institution.


There have been calls by BRICS and other developing nations that these top positions should better reflect the growing power and influence of emerging economies, which are now responsible for more than half of global economic growth.

Ngozi Okonjo-Iweala, Nigerian finance minister and former managing director of the World Bank under Zoellick, has gained the support of African leaders, while Brazil has nominated former Colombian finance minister Jose Antonio Ocampo.

But they face stiff opposition from the U.S.-nominated candidate Jim Yong Kim, a Korean-American health expert whose name was put forward by U.S. President Barack Obama on Friday.

Zoellick said all three candidates were "excellent", but added that the bank's senior leadership was already showing more and more representation from emerging economies.

"If you take the overall leadership at the bank, with all the different positions, it is more representative. I appointed the first chief economist who was from China," he said.

"At one point, the three managing directors that reported to me were all from the developing world. I think that it's not just a question of the head of organisation, but the organisation as a whole."

He said the decision on his successor would be made in April by the bank's board, which represents its 187 shareholders. The selection process is transparent and based on merit, he said, dismissing concerns by BRICS that it was heavily weighted in favour of the U.S. candidate.

The candidates will have to think through where they want to take the bank, he said, adding that the board of governors, will interview each of them to understand their plans for the future.

Zoellick who took over the bank in 2007 after serving as the U.S. deputy secretary of state, said it was good that Americans have a chance to run global institutions.

"The United States has never had anybody lead the IMF, they've never led the World Trade Organisation, they've never had anyone be the U.N. Secretary General, they've never had anybody lead the regional development banks," he said.

"So personally as an American, who has worked with multilateral organisations, it's good for Americans to have a chance to run some of them. Whether it's the World Bank or others, that's a whole different question."

(Editing by Frank Jack Daniel & Kim Coghill)

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see
Comments (1)
John_Darling wrote:
LOL! And if you ask the guy again, he will tell you in no unmistakable terms how the IMF is the top dog and nobody but nobody can ever beat them. Aaaaah, hubris!

Mar 29, 2012 7:46pm IST  --  Report as abuse
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.

  • Most Popular
  • Most Shared

Popularity Poll

Reuters Showcase

New Adviser

New Adviser

Arvind Subramanian likely to be chief econ adviser.  Full Article 

South Asia in Photos

South Asia in Photos

First pictures of Taj Mahal to ‘Hairy family of Burma’: subcontinent photos from 1850-1910.  Full Article 

Tracking Monsoon

Tracking Monsoon

Monsoon to display lull as floods ease  Full Article 

Growing Threat

Growing Threat

Islamic State threat 'beyond anything we've seen' - Pentagon.  Full Article 

Day of Mourning

Day of Mourning

Malaysia mourns as bodies of MH17 victims finally come home.  Full Article 

Water  Levels

Water Levels

Water reservoirs at 65 pct of capacity in past week.  Full Article 

U.S. Open

U.S. Open

Preview - Djokovic, Federer favored for grand slam sequel.  Full Article 

Film Review

Film Review

‘Katiyabaaz’ turns banal reality into gripping tale.  Full Article 

Goodbye Robin

Goodbye Robin

Robin Williams' ashes scattered in San Francisco Bay.  Full Article 

Reuters India Mobile

Reuters India Mobile

Get the latest news on the go. Visit Reuters India on your mobile device.  Full Coverage