BREAKINGVIEWS: SEBI's welcome market reform comes with a bonus

MUMBAI Tue May 29, 2012 4:12pm IST

Investors watch the share index at a local share market in Chandigarh October 10, 2008. REUTERS/Ajay Verma/Files

Investors watch the share index at a local share market in Chandigarh October 10, 2008.

Credit: Reuters/Ajay Verma/Files

Related Topics

Stocks

   

MUMBAI (Reuters Breakingviews) - The Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) has done the right thing in removing the option to settle serious cases of market abuse like insider trading. The SEBI's new regime now has a real incentive to secure hard convictions. The change won't be smooth - but that's not all bad news.

SEBI's detractors argue that the reform effectively passes the buck to a snail-paced and corrupt legal system. That's unfair. The legal system is by no means perfect, but in recent important cases it has proved to be robust and fairly speedy. The Supreme Court's Vodafone and 2G rulings this year have been both tough and timely.

Under the old system, settlements risked being seen as a no more than cost of doing business. They involve no admission of guilt. But just one landmark prosecution for SEBI would have a lasting deterrent effect. And the potential to settle cases has left SEBI vulnerable to political and financial pressure to do so. Last June, SEBI's former deputy wrote a remarkably anguished letter to the prime minister claiming that SEBI's chairman was being pressured by the finance ministry to go easy on powerful corporate groups under investigation by the regulator.

But the reform, while well flagged, has created some confusion. How are the new norms to be applied to active cases such as the one against Mukesh Ambani's Reliance, which dates back to 2007? The case concerns alleged breaches in connection with the sale of shares in the erstwhile Reliance Petroleum. Reliance has reportedly twice attempted to settle the case by consent, only to be rebuffed by SEBI. Are these probes subject to the new or the old regime?

One option which the regulator should consider is to create a window, say for three months, to allow parties under investigation to make final settlement offers. SEBI need not agree, and there could be a rather unseemly dash. But it would at least close the door firmly on the old system. And it would also create a strong incentive for the parties to make SEBI juicy offers that it would be hard to refuse.

CONTEXT NEWS

- The Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) said on May 28 that it would not settle serious cases, such as insider trading and unfair trade practices, through the use of consent orders -- a mechanism that avoids lengthy legal proceedings.

- The watchdog also said it would not consider an application for a consent order without completing investigations.

- SEBI Circular. click link.reuters.com/sux48s

- Request for information, click link.reuters.com/tux48s

(The author is a Reuters Breakingviews columnist. The opinions expressed are his own)

(Editing by Chris Hughes and David Evans)

FILED UNDER:
Comments (0)
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.

  • Most Popular
  • Most Shared

Markets

REUTERS SHOWCASE

Political Pulse

Political Pulse

100 days of Modi: Good for business, not so good for marginalised groups.  Full Article 

Segway in India

Segway in India

Segway’s India business pegs hope on tech-savvy Modi  Full Article 

Best Economy

Best Economy

Swiss economy most competitive once again; EU, U.S., Japan improve.  Full Article 

Power Outage

Power Outage

Mumbai hit by power cuts  Full Article 

Commodities

Commodities

Gold imports, premiums to jump on festive demand - top refiner  Full Article 

Economic Worries

Economic Worries

Pakistan's promises to IMF in doubt as protests sap economy   Full Article 

Islamic Finance

Islamic Finance

Basel III deposit challenge looms over Islamic banks   Full Article 

Antitrust Probes

Antitrust Probes

U.S. business lobby says concerned China antitrust probes unfair.  Full Article 

Reuters India Mobile

Reuters India Mobile

Get the latest news on the go. Visit Reuters India on your mobile device.  Full Coverage