COLUMN - India: from policy paralysis to parliament paralysis

Fri Aug 24, 2012 10:53pm IST

A view of the Indian parliament building is seen on the opening day of the monsoon session in New Delhi August 1, 2011. REUTERS/B Mathur/Files

A view of the Indian parliament building is seen on the opening day of the monsoon session in New Delhi August 1, 2011.

Credit: Reuters/B Mathur/Files

Related Topics

"Debate" is a word that doesn't appeal much to Indian political leaders, at least when they are in parliament.

The Comptroller and Auditor General's (CAG) report on a suspected coal scam dubbed ‘Coalgate' has been causing uproar in parliament for the past few days.

In a bid to drive political mileage from the report, the opposition has repeatedly stalled parliament, seeking the immediate resignation of Prime Minister Manmohan Singh.

But, given the current economic scenario where extensive debate and passage of reforms is the need of the hour, parliamentary paralysis is only adding to India's economic woes.

Perhaps in the golden years of India's economy, when we were growing at 9 percent, such disruptions wouldn't have raised as many eyebrows as they do today.

The various scams that surfaced over the recent years raise one common concern: loss to the exchequer, which is actually the common man's loss. But the loss to the exchequer when parliament doesn't function normally does not seem to cause discomfort.

Politicians might differ in their opinions and have a right to protest, but it should not be at the cost of disrupting the parliament. A media report (read here) reveals that the 15th Lok Sabha has lost 492 hours and 293 minutes in its ten sessions so far. It now needs 568 hours to finish legislative business lost to disruptions.

Some key bills are pending discussion, including the land acquisition bill and the banking laws amendment bill, which even led to a 2-day strike by bank staff this week.

When it comes to parliamentary activity, disruptions are a common sight in India. But it is time political leaders realise the economy needs to be pushed back on track with the speedy passage of reforms -- something that will only happen when the parliament functions the way it should.

Rather than playing the blame game, stringent measures should be adopted soon to discourage politicians from doing this.

Perhaps their salaries and allowances should be incentivised and linked to their performance, just like it happens in the corporate world.

There have been politicians, including Varun Gandhi and Omar Abdullah, who have favoured the ‘no-work no-pay' model. Though it is difficult to say whether such a model can fix things, it might just act as a deterrent.

But money cannot be the sole discouraging factor. Politicians will have to understand that these disruptions do not help achieve anything.

(Aditya Kalra is a Reuters journalist. The views and opinions expressed here are his own and not those of Reuters. You can contact Aditya at Follow him on Twitter at @adityayk)

Comments (0)
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.

  • Most Popular
  • Most Shared

Trade Deal


Record High

Record High

Nifty hits record high on foreign buying, higher Asian stocks.  Full Article 

Bullish on Equities

Bullish on Equities

Bullish on Indian equities, but gains seen 'less sharp'- Goldman Sachs  Full Article 



World Bank chief welcomes new BRICS development bank.  Full Article 

Streamlining Operations

Jet Streamlines

Jet Airways chairman says looking to restructure debts, talking to bankers  Full Article 

Political Economy

Political Economy

Analysis - Watch what markets don't do as world politics turns nasty   Full Article 


Honda's India Thrust

Honda's India unit to account for 25 pct of Asia Pacific sales by March 2017 - exec   Full Article 

 Boosting Output

Boosting Output

NMDC plans to boost iron ore output by two-thirds  Full Article 

Apple Results

Apple Results

Apple margin concerns fade, focus shifts to iPhone launch  Full Article 

Reuters India Mobile

Reuters India Mobile

Get the latest news on the go. Visit Reuters India on your mobile device.  Full Coverage