India revokes Roche patent in new blow for Big Pharma

MUMBAI/LONDON Sat Nov 3, 2012 6:28am IST

The logo of Swiss pharmaceutical company Roche is seen at the company's headquarters in Basel April 5, 2012. REUTERS/Arnd Wiegmann/Files

The logo of Swiss pharmaceutical company Roche is seen at the company's headquarters in Basel April 5, 2012.

Credit: Reuters/Arnd Wiegmann/Files

Related Topics

Stocks

   

MUMBAI/LONDON (Reuters) - India dealt a fresh blow to the international pharmaceutical industry on Friday as its patents appeal board revoked a patent granted six years ago on Roche's (ROG.VX) hepatitis C drug Pegasys.

The Intellectual Property Appellate Board (IPAB) cited a lack of evidence that the drug was any better than existing treatments and its high price as reasons for the decision.

Pegasys was the first medicine to win protection in 2006 under India's new patent regime and the revocation will rekindle tensions between New Delhi and global drugmakers worried by the country's tough stance.

The decision follows another high-profile setback for the industry in March, when India granted the first ever compulsory licence to domestic drugmaker Natco (NATP.NS) to sell cheap copies of Bayer's (BAYGn.DE) cancer drug Nexavar.

Multinational drug manufacturers see India's $12 billion drug market as a huge opportunity, but are wary of what they see as lax protection for intellectual property in a country where generic medicines account for more than 90 percent of sales.

Indian generic companies, which do not need to plough money back into future research, can produce drugs at a fraction of the cost of originator firms like Roche or Bayer.

Sankalp Rehabilitation Trust, an advocacy group for cheaper medicines, had challenged the Pegasys patent with the IPAB, saying the drug was costly and gave the Swiss company a monopoly in the market for the drug.

The market price of Pegasys is 436,000 rupees for 48 weeks of treatment, although it is also available at a discounted price of 314,496 rupees, Sankalp said in a statement.

Pegasys is given in combination with another drug, ribavirin, which costs 47,160 rupees for the same period, Sankalp added.

The appeals board on Friday termed Sankalp's plea "valid."

PAYING FOR INNOVATION

Roche, which can appeal the decision to the Supreme Court, said it was reviewing the IPAB decision and could not comment on it in detail. But it said a solid system of patent protection was essential to ensure research into new treatments.

"Many of the generic drugs today used in India were once patent-protected and are only available to society because companies such as Roche were willing to take a risk by investing in new innovative drugs," a company spokesman said.

He added that Roche was assessing a number of different ways to make drugs accessible to patients in poorer countries, including volume discounts, rebates and price capping.

Campaigners for greater healthcare access contend that the best way to ensure low drug prices is to maximise generic competition by challenging unjustified patents.

Leena Menghaney, a manager in New Delhi for Medecins Sans Frontieres (MSF), said this was particularly important in a disease area like hepatitis C, which is a growing problem in many Asian countries and often hits the most vulnerable in society.

"This case shows that if people choose to use different public health safeguards in Indian law to check abuse of the patent system, then indeed they do work," she said.

Another case involving drug patents is currently in front of India's the Supreme Court, with Novartis (NOVN.VX) battling against an earlier decision refusing it a patent on cancer drug Glivec.

India is also taking a tougher line on drug pricing more generally, with plans to increase dramatically the number of essential drugs subject to price regulation.

(Reporting by Kaustubh Kulkarni; Editing by Tony Munroe and David Cowell)

FILED UNDER:
Comments (0)
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.

  • Most Popular
  • Most Shared

Culling Plans

REUTERS SHOWCASE

Root Out 'Bad Apples'

Root Out 'Bad Apples'

RBI chief calls for cleaning up of banking system.  Full Article 

Android One

Android One

Google launches $105 Android One; eyes low-price smartphone boom.  Full Article 

India-Vietnam Ties

India-Vietnam Ties

India tightens Vietnam defence, oil ties ahead of China Xi's visit.  Full Article 

Cognizant Deal

Cognizant Deal

Cognizant to buy TriZetto for $2.7 billion to boost healthcare business  Full Article 

Inflation Eases

Inflation Eases

Aug WPI inflation eases to near five-year low of 3.74 percent  Full Article 

Kashmir Floods

Kashmir Floods

Disease threatens as Kashmir flood waters turn fetid  Full Article 

Hepatitis Drug

Hepatitis Drug

Gilead licenses hepatitis C drug to Cipla, Ranbaxy, five others   Full Article 

Trade Deficit

Trade Deficit

Exports growth slows to 2.4 pct in August  Full Article 

Battle for Heineken

Battle for Heineken

Four generations on, Heineken family won't loosen grip  Full Article 

Reuters India Mobile

Reuters India Mobile

Get the latest news on the go. Visit Reuters India on your mobile device.  Full Coverage