Texas school can force teenager to wear locator chip - judge

SAN ANTONIO Wed Jan 9, 2013 8:34am IST

Related Topics

Stocks

   

SAN ANTONIO (Reuters) - A public school district in Texas can require students to wear locator chips when they are on school property, a federal judge ruled on Tuesday in a case raising technology-driven privacy concerns among liberal and conservative groups alike.

U.S. District Judge Orlando Garcia said the San Antonio Northside School District had the right to expel sophomore Andrea Hernandez, 15, from a magnet school at Jay High School, because she refused to wear the device, which is required of all students.

The judge refused the student's request to block the district from removing her from the school while the case works its way through the federal courts.

The American Civil Liberties Union is among the rights organizations to oppose the district's use of radio frequency identification, or RFID, technology.

"We don't want to see this kind of intrusive surveillance infrastructure gain inroads into our culture," ACLU senior policy analyst Jay Stanley said. "We should not be teaching our children to accept such an intrusive surveillance technology."

The district's RFID policy has also been criticized by conservatives, who call it an example of "big government" further monitoring individuals and eroding their liberties and privacy rights.

The Rutherford Institute, a conservative Virginia-based policy center that represented Hernandez in her federal court case, said the ruling violated the student's constitutional right to privacy, and vowed to appeal.

The school district - the fourth largest in Texas with about 100,000 students - is not attempting to track or regulate students' activities, or spy on them, district spokesman Pascual Gonzalez said. Northside is using the technology to locate students who are in the school building but not in the classroom when the morning bell rings, he said.

Texas law counts a student present for purposes of distributing state aid to education funds based on the number of pupils in the classroom at the start of the day. Northside said it was losing $1.7 million a year due to students loitering in the stairwells or chatting in the hallways.

The software works only within the walls of the school building, cannot track the movements of students, and does not allow students to be monitored by third parties, Gonzalez said.

The ruling gave Hernandez and her father, an outspoken opponent of the use of RFID technology, until the start of the spring semester later this month to decide whether to accept district policy and remain at the magnet school or return to her home campus, where RFID chips are not required.

(Editing by Daniel Trotta and Peter Cooney)

FILED UNDER:

Microsoft in China

Tech Showcase

Samsung Sells Shares

Samsung Sells Shares

Samsung Group says to sell 4 units to Hanwha Group for $1.7 bln   Full Article 

HP Earnings

HP Earnings

HP fourth-quarter revenue drops on weak enterprise demand  Full Article 

Surveillance Saga

Surveillance Saga

U.N. committee spotlights 'highly intrusive' digital spying   Full Article 

Twitter Deal?

Twitter Deal?

Twitter in talks to buy Bieber-backed selfie app Shots - CNBC  Full Article 

Google in Europe

Google in Europe

United States says EU's Google case should not be politicised  Full Article 

Thanksgiving Ads

Thanksgiving Ads

Facebook video draws Thanksgiving ads from Macy's, others  Full Article 

Reuters India Mobile

Reuters India Mobile

Get the latest news on the go. Visit Reuters India on your mobile device.  Full Coverage