RBI officials fear budget choices give less room for rate cuts

MUMBAI Fri Feb 22, 2013 12:45pm IST

Two men make phone calls while standing near a Reserve Bank of India (RBI) crest at the RBI headquarters in Mumbai January 29, 2013. REUTERS/Vivek Prakash/Files

Two men make phone calls while standing near a Reserve Bank of India (RBI) crest at the RBI headquarters in Mumbai January 29, 2013.

Credit: Reuters/Vivek Prakash/Files

MUMBAI (Reuters) - India's austerity push in a budget to be unveiled on Thursday threatens to have the unintended impact of adding to inflationary pressure, hampering chances for rapid interest rate cuts that the government wants, RBI officials told Reuters.

New Delhi plans to cut public spending by up to 10 percent in the fiscal year starting in April, officials involved in the budget preparations told Reuters last week, as Finance Minister P. Chidambaram struggles to bring down the fiscal deficit to 4.8 percent of gross domestic product and stave off a credit rating downgrade.

Yet, officials in the Reserve Bank of India fear that cutting capital spending on projects with strong multiplier effects like building roads and bridges, won't help revive growth, which is seen as a priority if the economy is to avoid a downward spiral.

And they also worry that maintaining populist spending on subsidies for food, fuel, fertiliser and cooking gas will push up prices. While this spending, fuels consumer demand, especially for food, it is also a key driver of inflation in India.

"If spending on social schemes comes at the expense of capital expenditure, it will be bad," an official with direct knowledge of policymaking told Reuters. "Inflation will go up, and there will be food inflation from the demand side."

But with an election just a year away, Prime Minister Manmohan Singh's beleaguered government, facing a backlash for raising fuel prices as well as a string of corruption scandals, is in a bind.

It needs to get its fiscal house in order, but cutting the outlay on populist schemes would alienate voters, already upset over stubbornly high inflation.

"Given that election is around the corner, it would be difficult for the government to cut its social outlay. Cutting investment expenditure is a soft target," a second official involved with monetary policy-making told Reuters.

Asia's third-largest economy is on track to grow as little as 5 percent in the fiscal year that ends next month, its worst in a decade, even as inflation remains sticky near 7 percent.

To get the economy going, the government should ideally be spending on infrastructure, which would in turn kick start stalled private sector investment.

Investment in technology, better transport and storage for India's vast agriculture sector could also help dampen supply-side inflation pressures by reducing wastage.

Instead, some of the savings on capital investment planned in the budget will be reallocated to help fund a $22.27 billion food security bill, officials have told Reuters.

The central bank has privately expressed its discomfort to the finance ministry over high government spending towards consumption.

"The RBI wants less non-planned expenditure and more capital expenditure because it supports growth," a third senior official said. Non-planned expenditure refers mostly to subsidies and consumption-based spending.

None of the officials wanted to be identified because they are not allowed to speak to media.

The RBI is also concerned about a trillion rupee cash hoard that the government has piled up during the closing weeks of the current fiscal year as it desperately tries to bring the fiscal deficit within a targeted 5.3 percent.

Economists believe the government is holding onto the cash so it will be able to borrow less in 2013/14, and keep the credit rating agencies at bay.

The trouble is that taking that money out of circulation instead of putting it to work puts another drag on an economy already losing momentum, and dilutes the impact of a recent rate cut as banks keep deposit rates high in order to attract funds.

Graphic link.reuters.com/baw24t on fiscal deficit

India GDP, output and exports graphic link.reuters.com/qaw46s

GDP and investment growth graphic link.reuters.com/vep85t

The RBI has long resisted pressure from the government to cut interest rates, but relented slightly in January by reducing its policy repo rate by 25 basis points to 7.75 percent.

Making its first cut in nine months, the central bank warned that high food prices could exacerbate inflation in the latter half of 2013.

After that cut and fall in the annual inflation rate to 6.62 percent in January, the lowest in three years, economists have stuck with expectations that interest rates will only be able to come down another 0.75 percentage point over the course of the year.

Chidambaram wants the RBI to cut rates further to stimulate growth and in the bargain reduce the fiscal deficit, which would in turn lower government borrowing and spur private investment. That argument could be at risk if the central bank isn't convinced that inflation is under control.

RBI Governor Duvvuri Subbarao made clear last weekend, while attending a G20 summit in Moscow, that the central bank is looking beyond the headline figure of the government's budget deficit, and examining the type of spending cuts planned.

"It's very important, for growth to accelerate and for inflation to remain contained, that investments take place. For private investment to take place the government has to spend on capital expenditure, on infrastructure," Subbarao said.

"So while we look at the headline fiscal deficit number in the budget, we will look also at the quality of fiscal adjustment in determining our monetary policy stance." (Additional reporting by Maya Nikolaeva in Moscow; Editing by Suvashree Dey Choudhury and Tony Munroe and Simon Cameron-Moore)

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see http://blogs.reuters.com/fulldisclosure/2010/09/27/toward-a-more-thoughtful-conversation-on-stories/
Comments (1)
Subrabhama wrote:
The old English proverb is: “chicken or egg which comes first?” The Tamil proverb is that a mad man will be cured of his madness if he is married off; but he can get married only if he cured of his madness! The dilemma for the GOI is which comes first:Investment or infrastructure? The answer is obvious. Infrastructure has the prime role and can come only from public intervention and not from private enterprise. The so-called PPP has led to cronyism and not visible projects. Infra projects have very long horizons and returns are very, very low. They are unsuited for private investment. The World Bank and the IMF which went over the top for two decades to promote PSI (private sector involvement) in infra had to confess that it was a colossal mistake. It had put back infra development in many emerging economies, especially India which was highly depended on foreign aid. Now the abysmal state of infra is staring in their eyes. They are blaming the RBI for keeping interest rate high and preventing investment. The RBI seems to have greater economic wisdom than the mandarins in North Block. However, it doesn’t stop them from putting the blame on the RBI. It is pathetic and is not going to help the country. anybody.

Feb 22, 2013 8:37pm IST  --  Report as abuse
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.

  • Most Popular
  • Most Shared
Sensex up over 300 points on energy reform, elections

Sensex up over 300 points on energy reform, elections

The BSE Sensex surges over 300 points and the Nifty gains more than 100 points after the government's energy reforms lead to a rally in energy firms, while wins by Prime Minister Narendra Modi's party in two state elections raise expectations for additional reforms.  Full Article 


State Elections

State Elections

Modi's BJP makes big gains in state polls.  Full Article 



India delays decision on iron ore licence for POSCO's $12 bln plant.  Full Article 

HCL Tech Results

HCL Tech Results

Quarterly profit up 32 percent, shares fall   Full Article 

Ebola Vaccine

Ebola Vaccine

GSK says Ebola vaccine development progressing at "unprecedented rate".  Full Article 

Health Check

Health Check

Credibility meets compromise in Europe's bank stress test.  Full Article 


Legal Reforms

Companies look for more fairness as China eyes legal reforms at key meeting.  Full Article 

Gold Smuggling

Gold Smuggling

With seizures up, Indian gold smuggling loses its shine  Full Article 

Reuters India Mobile

Reuters India Mobile

Get the latest news on the go. Visit Reuters India on your mobile device.  Full Coverage