Madoff indirect investors lose U.S. court appeal

Sat Feb 23, 2013 12:18am IST

Related Topics

REUTERS - People who lost money by investing in funds that funneled their money to Bernard Madoff's Ponzi scheme are not entitled to recover for their losses, in the manner that direct victims of the massive fraud can recover, a federal appeals court ruled on Friday.

The decision by the 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in New York is a victory for Irving Picard, the trustee liquidating Bernard L Madoff Investment Securities LLC and seeking money for its former customers.

Picard, a partner at Baker & Hostetler, persuaded the court that "indirect" investors who lost money in the fraud were not Madoff customers who could recover from the bankruptcy estate.

Madoff, 74, is serving a 150-year prison sentence, and Picard had estimated that customers lost $17.3 billion of principal in the fraud.

The appeal was brought by 17 investors who had invested in limited partnerships known as Spectrum Select. These in turn sent their money to two Rye Select hedge funds overseen by Tremont Group Holdings Inc.

Tremont was one of the largest Madoff "feeders," and settled with Picard for $1.025 billion in July 2011.

Prior to the appeal, two lower court judges had found that the 17 indirect investors could not recover from the estate because they had not been Madoff customers, unlike the feeder funds that dealt directly with him.

That distinction matters because it is customers, not indirect investors, who may draw up to $500,000 each from a fund overseen by the Securities Investor Protection Corp, to the extent they cannot recover losses from a bankruptcy estate.

SIPC is a nonprofit created by Congress and funded by the brokerage industry.

CRITICAL REQUIREMENT NOT SATISFIED

Writing for a three-judge 2nd Circuit panel, Circuit Judge Reena Raggi said there were several reasons that the indirect investors did not qualify as Madoff customers.

She said they had no direct relationship or accounts with his firm, were not identified in the firm's books and records, had no property interest in the assets sent there by the feeder funds, and lacked control over the feeder funds' investments.

"We have identified the critical aspect of the 'customer' definition to be the entrustment of cash or securities to the broker-dealer for the purpose of trading securities," Raggi wrote. "Appellants fail to satisfy this critical requirement."

William Chapman, who argued the indirect investors' appeal, did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

A spokeswoman for Picard did not immediately respond to a similar request.

The decision does not affect the ability of indirect investors to sue the feeder funds, or share in any recovery by those funds from the SIPC fund.

Friday's decision is the second this week by the 2nd Circuit in a Madoff-related appeal.

On Wednesday, the court refused to let former investors pursue claims against Madoff's brother Peter, as well as Madoff's son Andrew and the estate of his late son Mark, over the family members' roles in the fraud.

The court said allowing such claims would impede Picard's effort to maximize payouts from the estate.

Among the investors who had challenged the trustee was a charitable foundation for New Jersey Senator Frank Lautenberg.

Separately, Picard on February 13 asked U.S. Bankruptcy Judge Burton Lifland in Manhattan for permission to distribute another $505 million to customers, boosting the total to $5.44 billion.

The case is Kruse et al v. Securities Investor Protection Corp et al, 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, Nos. 12-410, 12-437, 12-483 and 12-529. (Reporting by Jonathan Stempel in New York; Editing by Phil Berlowitz)

FILED UNDER:
Comments (0)
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.

  • Most Popular
  • Most Shared

Economy

REUTERS SHOWCASE

Pharma Sector

Pharma Sector

In race for bigger margins, drug makers willing to lose the India "advantage".  Full Article 

Jan Dhan Yojna

Jan Dhan Yojna

Modi: Banking for all to end "financial untouchability".  Full Article 

Power Outage

Power Outage

India may face blackouts as coal shortage cuts power output  Full Article 

Moody's on Inflation

Moody's on Inflation

Persistent inflation hurting India's sovereign ratings - Moody's  Full Article 

Tracking Monsoon

Tracking Monsoon

Monsoon forecast to be better for crops next week  Full Article 

Carmichael Project

Carmichael Project

Adani buys Australia coal mine royalty rights from Linc for $145 million  Full Article 

GDP Preview

GDP Preview

Economy likely grew faster in June quarter: Reuters poll.  Full Article 

India-Japan Meet

India-Japan Meet

Modi eyes breakthrough nuclear pact on Japan trip   Full Article 

Rare Earth Output

Rare Earth Output

India to chip in with 5 pct of global rare earth output  Full Article 

Reuters India Mobile

Reuters India Mobile

Get the latest news on the go. Visit Reuters India on your mobile device.  Full Coverage