U.S. judge throws out Abu Ghraib detainees' torture case

Thu Jun 27, 2013 5:02am IST

Paintings by Colombian artist Fernando Botero from his Abu Ghraib collection are displayed at the Arts Center in the northern city of Monterrey February 7, 2008. REUTERS/Tomas Bravo/Files

Paintings by Colombian artist Fernando Botero from his Abu Ghraib collection are displayed at the Arts Center in the northern city of Monterrey February 7, 2008.

Credit: Reuters/Tomas Bravo/Files

Related Topics

Stocks

   

(Reuters) - CACI International Inc(CACI.N) has won the dismissal of a lawsuit accusing it of conspiring to torture detainees at the Abu Ghraib prison near Baghdad, as the defense contractor benefited from a recent U.S. Supreme Court decision over alleged human rights abuses on foreign soil.

In a decision made public on Wednesday, U.S. District Judge Gerald Bruce Lee in Alexandria, Virginia said he lacked jurisdiction to hear claims brought by the four Iraqi plaintiffs under the Alien Tort Statute (ATS), and separate claims by one plaintiff that he said were barred under Iraqi law.

Lee ruled eight months after Engility Holdings Inc (EGL.N), a spinoff of L-3 Communications Holdings Inc (LLL.N), paid $5.28 million to settle similar claims against an L-3 unit by roughly six dozen people who were once held in Abu Ghraib and other Iraqi prisons.

Photos depicting abuse of Abu Ghraib detainees emerged in 2004. While no contractors were charged, some detainees accused their workers in lawsuits of physical and sexual abuse, inflicting electric shocks, and conducting mock executions.

In the case against CACI, however, Lee said the Alien Tort Statute claims could not proceed, because the relevant activity took place in Iraq and was not covered under the Supreme Court's April 17 decision in Kiobel v. Royal Dutch Petroleum Co.

There, Chief Justice John Roberts said the law was presumed to cover international law violations occurring in the United States, and that violations elsewhere must "touch and concern" U.S. territory "with sufficient force" before people could sue.

Lee said the CACI plaintiffs' claims fell short.

"Plaintiffs alleged that torture and war crimes occurred during their detention in Abu Ghraib," he wrote. "Plaintiffs' ATS claims do not allege that any violations occurred in the United States or any of its territories. Therefore, on these facts, the court holds that Kiobel's bar against extraterritorial application of the ATS governs."

Baher Azmy, legal director of Center for Constitutional Rights, who represents the CACI plaintiffs, plans to appeal.

"We argued there were no post-Kiobel decisions with stronger connections to the United States than ours," he said in a phone interview. "You had a U.S.-based company that contracted with the U.S. government to provide interrogation services to U.S.-occupied Iraq and conspired with U.S. soldiers to torture and abuse detainees.

"We're disappointed in the ruling and level of impunity it provides for human rights abuses undertaken by U.S. entities," Azmy added.

CACI said in a statement: "We are gratified by the court's decision and hope this is the end of these baseless lawsuits."

A federal appeals court in Richmond, Virginia had in May 2012 allowed the lawsuits against CACI and L-3 to proceed.

CACI is based in Arlington, Virginia.

The case is Al Shimari et al v. CACI International Inc et al, U.S. District Court, Eastern District of Virginia, No. 08-00827. (Additional reporting by Terry Baynes; Editing by Carol Bishopric)

FILED UNDER:

Sony Cyber Attack

REUTERS SHOWCASE

Exit Polls

Exit Polls

BJP unlikely to form Jammu & Kashmir govt - polls.  Full Article 

Forceful Conversions

Forceful Conversions

BJP distances itself from religious conversions.  Full Article 

Photo

Fund Raising

Flipkart raises $700 million in fresh funding.   Full Article 

Reforms Push

Reforms Push

Modi may order insurance, coal reforms if vote delayed - officials.  Full Article 

Economic Pulse

Economic Pulse

Crank up public spending to revive growth - chief economic adviser.  Full Article 

Reuters Exclusive

Reuters Exclusive

India looks to sway Americans with nuclear power insurance plan  Full Article 

Down Under

Down Under

Magic Johnson inspires Australia to second test win.  Full Article 

Going International

Going International

Bollywood’s Priyanka Chopra sets sights on American TV.  Full Article 

India This Week

India This Week

Some of our best photos from this week.   Full Coverage 

Reuters India Mobile

Reuters India Mobile

Get the latest news on the go. Visit Reuters India on your mobile device   Full Coverage