No apology as Channel Nine defends Hotspot reporting

SYDNEY Fri Aug 9, 2013 11:04am IST

England's captain Alastair Cook pictured during a news conference before the fourth Ashes cricket test match against Australia at the Riverside cricket ground in Chester-le-Street near Durham August 8, 2013. REUTERS/Philip Brown

England's captain Alastair Cook pictured during a news conference before the fourth Ashes cricket test match against Australia at the Riverside cricket ground in Chester-le-Street near Durham August 8, 2013.

Credit: Reuters/Philip Brown

SYDNEY (Reuters) - Australia's Channel Nine TV on Friday defended its reporting of the use of silicone tape on cricket bats to confuse Hotspot technology during the Ashes series, saying they had not made allegations about players cheating.

Amid increasing controversy during the five-test Ashes series over the inconsistency of the Decision Review System (DRS), the network reported on Wednesday that the International Cricket Council (ICC) was investigating the matter.

The ICC, cricket's governing body, issued an immediate denial and said the report was "totally incorrect".

England captain Alastair Cook on Thursday described the claims as a "blatant fabrication" and demanded an apology from the network.

"We have been reporting on the story and have never made any allegations about players cheating," a Network Nine spokeswoman said by e-mail on Friday.

"Concerns about the use of tape on bats reducing the effectiveness of Hotspot have come from the creator of the technology, Warren Brennan.

"He raised these concerns with the ICC. As a result, extensive testing has been carried out by Brennan and the ICC has conceded that there may be an issue worth further investigation."

The Ashes series has been dogged by controversial umpiring decisions and there have been several occasions when Hotspot has failed to pick up edges.

England's leading batsman Kevin Pietersen was involved in one such incident during the third test in Manchester when he was given out caught behind, even though nothing appeared on the Hotspot review.

ABSURD

The initial Channel Nine report said "concerns" over the matter "centred on Kevin Pietersen's dismissal" and the batsman responded furiously on Twitter.

"Horrible journalism yet again! My name brought up in Hotspot crisis suggesting I use silicon(e) infuriates me," he wrote on his Twitter feed.

"I am never afraid of getting out! If I nick it, I'll walk .... to suggest I cheat by covering my bat with silicon(e) infuriates me.

"How stupid would I be to try & hide a nick when it could save me on an LBW appeal, like in 1st innings where hotspot showed I nicked it."

Cook called the Channel Nine report "absurd" and "blatantly untrue", although he added that the prevailing emotion in both the England and Australian dressing room had been one of amusement.

"Both sides have kind of laughed at it," he said. "Certainly we've been laughing at it in our dressing room because of how strange the story is.

"The mileage it's been given has been a bit strange and it's not great when you've been called a cheat as a side and have been accused of something you haven't done."

England are 2-0 up in the series and have already clinched the Ashes ahead of the fourth test, which starts in Durham later on Thursday. (Editing by Patrick Johnston)

REUTERS SHOWCASE

Golf Update

Golf Update

Rory McIlroy has Georgia on his mind Down Under.  Full Article | Captain speaks 

Vettori Returns

Vettori Returns

Vettori back for New Zealand, Pakistan bat first in Sharjah.  Full Article 

Messi Record

Messi Record

Messi treble sets Champions League goals record  Full Article | Mourinho delight 

Aguero Hat-trick

Aguero Hat-trick

Aguero treble keeps Manchester City in contention  Full Article | Related Story 

Chelsea Win

Chelsea Win

Chelsea qualify in style with five-goal romp  Full Article | Related Story 

FIFA Trouble

FIFA Trouble

Hard to quantify damage done by non publication of report - Valcke  Full Article 

Reuters India Mobile

Reuters India Mobile

Get the latest news on the go. Visit Reuters India on your mobile device  Full Coverage