U.S. Supreme Court refuses challenge to California climate rule

June 30 Tue Jul 1, 2014 12:50am IST

June 30 (Reuters) - The U.S. Supreme Court on Monday declined to hear a challenge to California's landmark low-carbon fuel standard, in a blow to out-of-state ethanol and gasoline producers that say the rule unfairly discriminates against their products.

A coalition of fuel makers, led by the Rocky Mountain Farmers Union, a grower of corn and soybeans for ethanol in western states, brought a lawsuit to overturn a 2009 rule mandating cuts in carbon emissions.

The California regulation calculates emissions throughout the life cycle of a fuel by including pollution from production as well as ultimate use.

Out-of-state fuel producers claim the standard penalizes them by calculating long transportation distances as part of the overall carbon footprint of their fuels.

They argued the measure violates the U.S. Constitution by interfering with interstate commerce but lost at the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals.

The Supreme Court's denial means the standard remains in place. The case will now be sent back to a lower court.

"Today's Supreme Court decision is a victory for everyone committed to taking meaningful action to tackle climate change," Mary Nichols, chairman of the California Air Resources Board, said in an emailed statement.

"It sends a clear message that the time for delay is over and the time to clean up and diversify transportation fuels is now," she said.

Richard Moskowitz, general counsel for American Fuel & Petrochemical Manufacturers, called the decision not to review the case disappointing.

"California's efforts to dictate how fuel is produced outside of its borders ignores constitutional safeguards that have long protected against one state controlling the conduct of private parties," he said in a statement.

He said the organization's members had yet to decide their next steps for the litigation.

California says the standard, created by an executive order of former Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger, is successfully slashing greenhouse gases to battle climate change.

The Environmental Defense Fund and the American Lung Association say the measure also reduces heart and lung diseases, health problems linked to poor air quality.

"This is another case of Big Oil and Big Ethanol trying to avoid cleaning up their act," attorney David Pettit from the Natural Resources Defense Council said in an emailed release.

Under California's regulation, fuel blenders and distributors must reduce the "carbon intensity" of their products by up to 10 percent over the next decade or risk being shut out of the state's lucrative market.

While California's program is the first of its kind in the country, other states such as Washington and Oregon have considered pursuing similar policies.

The case is Rocky Mountain Farmers Union v. Richard W. Corey, U.S. Supreme Court, No. 13-1148. (Additional reporting by Rory Carroll in San Francisco; Editing by Howard Goller and Steve Orlofsky)

Comments (0)
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.

  • Most Popular
  • Most Shared

Consumer Confidence Index

REUTERS SHOWCASE

Deal Talk

Deal Talk

Exclusive - Lupin, U.S. firms weigh bids for GSK's mature drugs: sources  Full Article 

Classifying Banks

Classifying Banks

RBI to start announcing too-big-to-fail banks in Aug 2015  Full Article 

Corruption Probe

Corruption Probe

India to probe corruption in healthcare after TV sting.  Full Article 

Food Scandal

Food Scandal

Starbucks, Burger King dragged in as China food scandal spreads.  Full Article 

Bigger iPhones

Bigger iPhones

Apple asks suppliers to produce up to 80 mln large-screen iPhones - WSJ.  Full Article 

Bali Trade Deal

Bali Trade Deal

India keeps world guessing in countdown to landmark trade pact deadline.  Full Article 

Bangalore Sex Abuse

Bangalore Sex Abuse

Modi's BJP puts political twist on local sex abuse case   Full Article 

Yahoo to buy Flurry

Yahoo to buy Flurry

Yahoo to buy analytics startup Flurry to bolster mobile ad business.  Full Article 

Wholesale Biz

Wholesale Biz

Wal-Mart adds $102.9 million in Indian wholesale business in June.  Full Article 

Reuters India Mobile

Reuters India Mobile

Get the latest news on the go. Visit Reuters India on your mobile device.  Full Coverage