Do More With Reuters
Partner Services

U.S. appeal raises business method patent issues

Wed May 7, 2008 11:17pm IST
 
Email | Print | | Single Page
[-] Text [+]

WASHINGTON, May 7 (Reuters) - Software companies and other businesses are watching closely as a U.S appeals court weighs whether an inventor can patent an abstract process -- something that involves nothing more than thoughts.

The case could further define the scope of "business method patents," which were widely considered unpatentable until a 1998 ruling allowed them. The U.S. Patent and Trademark Office issued 1,330 such patents last year, up from 120 in 1997, according to figures on its website.

In this suit, Bernard Bilski and Rand Warsaw are challenging the patent office's rejection of their request for a patent on a method for managing the risk of sudden movements in energy costs.

Oral arguments in the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit are scheduled for Thursday.

Michael Warnecke, a former patent examiner and now a lawyer with Perkins Coie LLP, said the Bilski case is essentially another look at the court's 1998 "State Street" ruling which allowed the patenting of a plan to administer mutual funds.

"It's a frontal attack on... State Street," Warnecke said. "I think they're going to say that business method patents can be patented."

The Bilski case is being closely watched by companies which use business method patents such as Amazon's (AMZN.O: Quote, Profile, Research) one-click method of buying products on the Internet.

Brian Kahin, an intellectual property expert with the Computer and Communications Industry Association, said he opposed granting patents for business methods because of the litigation that could result from inevitable, inadvertent infringement.

"There's so many patents and you're operating in an environment where you've got to have a lot of functionality," he said. "The more complex your product, the more potential there is that there's patents in there."  Continued...

Dubai Debt Fears

Villas are seen on the The Palm, Jumeirah, with Atlantis, The Palm, under construction on the breakwater (crescent), May 3, 2008.  REUTERS/Jumana El Heloueh

Banks outside the Gulf played down their exposure to Dubai debt, after fears the emirate could default and even derail world economic recovery prompted a sell-off in global markets.  Full Article | Slideshow 

India Investment Summit 2009
India Investment Summit 2009

Top executives and bankers discuss their own plans and the broader opportunities and challenges for India.  Full Coverage 

People stroll outside the Taj Mahal hotel ahead of the first anniversary of the militant attacks in Mumbai, November 24, 2009.  REUTERS/Punit Paranjpe
Investors worry about another attack

The risk of militants striking again worries investors who fear that a second attack similar to last year's Mumbai raids could shake the economy.  Full Article | Full Coverage 

Market Update

  • IndiaIndia
  • USUS
  • UKUK
  • Asia
  • Most Actives

road to Copenhagen

BLOGS

Photo
Calculated Move

Reliance aims big with $12 bln bid for LyondellBasell.  Blog 

SHOWCASE

Capital Raising
Capital Raising

Analysis - China banks' rush for billions could trip markets.  Full Article 

 
Photo
Bonus Payout

"Bonus" has become a dirty word on Wall Street.  Full Article 

 
Bubble trouble?
Bubble trouble?

With the BSE Sensex at around 17,000 points, are the Indian equity markets looking at a possible bubble?   Commentary 

 
Funding Blues
Funding Blues

A popular tactic used by Indian brokerages to raise money for rich clients is likely to be banned.  Full Article 

 
Recovery Path
Recovery Path

Indian techie logging out of downturn gloom.  Full Article 

 
Central Banks Cautious
Central Banks Cautious

Reuters tracks the policies of the world's top central banks as the debate over global economic recovery rages on.   Full Coverage 

 
Risky Proposal
Risky Proposal

Rupert Murdoch courts trouble if he blocks Google on news.  Full Article