Do More With Reuters
Partner Services

FACTBOX-Comparison of US House, Senate climate bills

Wed Oct 7, 2009 1:53am IST
 
Email | Print | | Single Page
[-] Text [+]

Oct 6 (Reuters) - Democrats in the U.S. Senate have sketched out their version of a climate change bill they plan to work on in coming weeks.

Many Senate details still need to be decided. But the legislation proposed by Senators John Kerry and Barbara Boxer embraces central elements of the bill passed in June by the House of Representatives, which attempts to reduce U.S. emissions of carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases blamed for global warming.

Here are key similarities and differences between the two measures, which are a long way from being enacted into law:

* CAP AND TRADE: The House-passed bill and the Senate proposal both have cap and trade at their core. Under the system, the federal government would put limits, continually declining, on the amount of carbon pollution from stationary sources. Companies would need an annual permit for every ton of carbon pollution they release into the atmosphere. Utilities and factories that don't use all of their permits could trade, or sell them, to companies that need more.

* EMISSION REDUCTIONS: The Senate shoots for a 20 percent cut in smokestack pollution by 2020. The House-passed bill sets a 17 percent reduction from 2005 levels. Some moderates in the Senate undoubtedly will try to lower the goal to 14 percent.

Both bills have the same long-term goals: an 83 percent cut in U.S. carbon pollution by 2050.

* EPA POWERS: The Senate proposal would leave the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency with powers to further regulate greenhouse gas emissions, while the House-passed bill does not.

* FREE POLLUTION PERMITS: Eighty-five percent of the pollution permits companies would have to obtain would initially be given away by the government, with 15 percent sold, under the House bill. In 2026, many of the free permits would begin switching to those that must be sold. While some analysts have said the Senate bill would have a 75 percent-25 percent split between free versus auctioned permits, Senator John Kerry told Reuters his bill will end up being very similar to the House bill on this point.

* ALLOCATION OF PERMITS: The Senate bill does not settle the controversial question of how many free permits key industry sectors will get. Lobbyists and Senate staff are in the midst of those negotiations. This was a tough battle in the House, which ended up giving 30 percent of all free permits to local electric distribution companies, 15 percent to cement, steel, glass and other big energy-using firms, 9 percent to local natural gas distributors, 3 percent for companies making electric and advanced technology vehicles and 2 percent for oil refiners.   Continued...

Construction workers work at a site as the sun sets in Chandigarh in this December 2006 file photo. REUTERS/Ajay Verma
Economy seen growing at 7.2 pct in FY10 - govt

The forecast reinforces the possibility that the government may start to unwind its fiscal stimulus in the budget.  Full Article 

Market Update

  • IndiaIndia
  • USUS
  • UKUK
  • Asia
  • Most Actives
Greece's Finance Minister Papaconstantinou addresses reporters during a news conference in Athens, January 20, 2010.
Eurozone agreed in principle to aid Greece

Euro zone countries have decided in principle to help debt-stricken Greece, a senior German ruling coalition source said.  Full Article 

FROM THE MARKETS

After the Bell
After the Bell

Reuters Money's Kshitij Anand updates you on the movers and shakers of the Indian stock market.  Blog 

SHOWCASE

"Claw Back" Pay
"Claw Back" Pay

Banks and regulators hope that threats to "claw back" pay if trades later blow up will rein in risk taking on Wall Street.  Full Article 

 
James Saft
Blaming Asperger's

COLUMN - Did Asperger's help cause the financial crisis?  Full Article 

 
Going Global
Going Global

With Volvo, Chinese eye M&A abroad to win at home.  Full Article 

 
Delivery Woes
Delivery Woes

Boeing 787 delivery schedule could slip - experts.  Full Article 

 
Central Banks Cautious
Central Banks Cautious

Reuters tracks the policies of the world's top central banks as the debate over global economic recovery rages on.   Full Coverage