TEXT-Fitch release on Energy Transfer Partners
(The following statement was released by the ratings agency)
March 25 - Fitch rates Energy Transfer Partners, LP's (ETP.N: Quote, Profile, Research) (ETP) proposed offering of $1.0 billion senior notes at 'BBB-'. The notes are expected to be issued in three tranches due 2013, 2018 and 2038. Note proceeds will be used to repay a $500 million term loan with the remainder used to reduce outstanding revolving credit borrowings. The Issuer Default Rating (IDR) for ETP is 'BBB-'. The Rating Outlook is Stable.
ETP's rating and Stable Rating Outlook reflect the increasing scale, scope, and diversity of its operations, strong quantitative credit measures, a conservative distribution policy, a favorable near-term regional natural gas supply position from expanding Barnett Shale and Bossier Sands development, and the expected benefits of ongoing contractually supported pipeline expansions. ETP's credit measures are consistent with its peer group of investment grade master limited partnerships (MLPs). However, a substantial capital spending program directed mostly toward pipeline expansion projects, estimated to approximate $1.8 billion for calendar 2008, will result in increased debt leverage until the new projects generate operating returns.
In December 2007, ETP raised approximately $270 million in new equity proceeds. Management is committed to periodically issue new equity throughout the current construction phase. ETP's debt-to-EBITDA for the twelve months ended December 2007 was approximately 3.4 times (x). Debt leverage will move higher in 2008 but should remain consistent with its rating category, albeit at the high end of the range for its MLP peer group. Maintaining appropriate future leverage measures will in good part depend on ETP completing timely equity financings.
On Sept. 12, 2007, Fitch changed ETP's Rating Outlook to Stable from Positive. The rating action was primarily the result of legal proceedings commenced against the company by the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) and The U.S. Commodities Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) relating for the most part to charges of natural gas market manipulation or attempted gas market manipulation. On March 17, 2008, it was announced that the legal action brought against ETP by CFTC was dismissed. In a consent order ETP agreed to pay CFTC $10 million while CFTC agreed to release ETP from claims it had brought against the company. The agreement between ETP and the CFTC contains no findings of fact or conclusions of law. However, resolution to the FERC case could extend well into calendar 2009 and beyond and continues to have a negative overhang on ETP's operations. Currently, FERC's enforcement staff is recommending penalties against ETP and its affiliates totaling $198 million. The size of a future settlement, if any, or the results of a fully litigated case cannot be determined at this stage. However, eventual payments to FERC and any potential third party claims could be material.
The uncertainty caused by the regulatory proceedings has most certainly contributed to increasing ETP's borrowing costs and depressing the market value of its LP units. ETP's $2.0 billion revolving credit facility maturing in 2012 is expandable to $3.0 billion. Fitch estimates that approximately $1.1 billion will be outstanding under the facility following the issuance of the new notes. In addition, Midcontinent Express Pipeline (MEP) has established a $1.4 billion three-year bank credit facility severally guaranteed by its 50% sponsors, ETP and Kinder Morgan Energy Partners, L.P. (KMP) to provide construction period financing for the project. While ETP's liquidity is adequate for the near term, given its aggressive capital budget, an impaired ability to issue long-term debt and equity would have negative credit implications.
While ETP's track record of acquiring, integrating and expanding energy infrastructure assets has been favorable, several challenges remain. Of ongoing concern is the event and integration risk inherent in ETP's active growth strategy. In particular, given the industry-wide inflation of pipeline construction costs and their effect on project economics, Fitch will continue to monitor the status of Transwestern's $710 million pipeline expansion into Phoenix and the development of the $1.3 billion MEP joint venture with KMP.
In addition to its ongoing legal proceedings, factors also considered by Fitch in ETP's rating analysis include: the structural subordination of the ETP notes to approximately $768 million of combined subsidiary debt at Transwestern and Heritage Operating L.P. (Heritage); the financial exposure to changes in commodity price and supply and demand conditions across its operations; and the structural relationships between affiliated companies, including approximately $1.57 billion of debt at Energy Transfer Equity, L.P. (ETE, IDR rated 'BB-' by Fitch).
A MLP, ETP is principally engaged in natural gas midstream and intrastate transportation and storage operations through La Grange Acquisition, L.P., interstate transportation of natural gas through Transwestern, and retail propane distribution through Titan Energy Partners, L.P. and Heritage. ETE owns approximately 62.5 million ETP limited partner (LP) units and ETP's 2% general partner interest. (New York Ratings Team)
© Thomson Reuters 2008 All rights reserved














