By Tom Miles
GENEVA, Sept 4 Candidates to replace Pascal Lamy
as head of the World Trade Organization when the Frenchman steps
down in a year's time are warming up for a contest that looks
likely to become another round of international horse trading.
Emerging market countries will want to see one of their own
in charge of the Geneva-based trading club, after the top jobs
at the International Monetary Fund and the World Bank went to a
European and an American.
But there are already signs that developing nations will
squabble over the identity of their candidate, meaning the race
for the job overseeing negotiations to reform global farm
subsidies, customs and trading rules is wide open.
"It's a multi-dimensional chess game," said one ambassador
to the WTO. "As in any election, you have to choose the best
moment to put your cards on the table."
Lamy's tenure at the WTO has been marked by Russia's
accession last month, and disputes, notably a trans-Atlantic row
over aircraft subsidies between Boeing and Airbus. But
most of all, it has been overshadowed by the failure to agree on
any reform of the world trade rules.
Whoever succeeds him will find unfinished negotiations over
trade liberalisation and competing claims from different
regional and economic blocs about what the next steps should be.
Reviving the Doha round of trade talks risks getting bogged
down in old arguments and driving the WTO into obsolescence but
a bold bid to shake things up is bound to be divisive.
The job is tough because, beyond shaping the agenda and
cajoling and persuading, the Director General has few powers
with which to steer the 157 members of the global trade club.
Formal nominations are not due until December, but trade
diplomats are already assessing chances and gathering names.
"It's very early days. We look forward to a competitive
process with a slate of very good candidates," said the WTO's
chief spokesman Keith Rockwell.
So far, only two have said they want the job.
One is New Zealand's Trade Minister Tim Groser, who starts
with a double disadvantage: most diplomats say it is the
"developing countries' turn", and New Zealand has already held
the job once in the WTO's 17 year history.
One trade negotiator said it would be "very peculiar" for
two of the WTO's first six chiefs to come from the same small,
Another said he regularly met Groser and said he was "very
down to earth. But another New Zealander? I don't think so."
The other name in the hat is Ghana's former trade minister
Alan Kyerematen, whose candidacy was approved without fanfare by
the African Union (AU) at a meeting in Addis Ababa in July.
Trade diplomats say that Lamy's replacement should be
African, Latin American or Caribbean, while Asia is seen to be
well-represented in world trade already thanks to the export
strength of China, India and Japan.
So an African unity candidate would be one to beat. No
previous candidate has managed to get the AU's backing.
"If he gets 54 African countries to start in his corner,
then that's big," said one trade official in Geneva.
But senior officials from other countries that could join
the race were dismissive and angry at what one called Ghana's
attempt to "pre-empt" the contest.
"One would have expected that the AU would have looked at
the totality of African candidates and who would have been best
to build a candidature around," said one source. "I'm not even
sure if some members of the AU candidature committee are members
of the WTO."
Several sources said the AU's approval of Kyerematen was
part of a deal to allow Nkosazana Dlamini-Zuma, a South African
Minister and ex-wife of President Jacob Zuma, to win election to
the chair of the AU.
"So there was this agreement to nominate this Ghanaian
minister as the candidate from Africa," said one WTO diplomat.
"From what I've heard, as soon as the meeting was over, others
said 'No way'."
"DEAD ON ARRIVAL"
If there was such a deal, it still may not protect
Kyerematen from a South African challenge. Zuma's Trade Minister
Rob Davies has been approached by others wanting him to run,
although South Africa has not yet decided whether to put forward
a candidate, Davies' spokesman Sidwell Medupe said.
"That depends on the outcome of discussions within our own
country as well as with others," Medupe said in emailed replies
to Reuters questions. Asked if South Africa would back
Kyerematen, he said: "We are assessing that."
However, Geneva-based diplomats bristled at the idea of
Davies as the next head of the WTO.
"We accept that this is a good candidacy," said one trade
negotiator. "The problem with Rob is that he's at one end of the
spectrum. He's very negative with ideas of negotiating
"He would be dead on arrival," said another. "I would like
to see the Americans agreeing to him being the Director General.
He's a hardliner. One of the main obstructionists, according to
the U.S. and the Europeans."
He added that Davies' potential candidacy may also be an
attempt to secure another Geneva post - as head of the U.N.
Conference on Trade and Development (UNCTAD), currently run by
Supachai Panitchpakdi, himself a former WTO Director General.
"I know for a fact that Rob has been in some way trying to
ask people to support him to be secretary general of UNCTAD. If
Africa gets the UNCTAD job, it's Latin America at the WTO," he
Kyerematen could also face a strong challenge from Nigeria,
Africa's second-biggest economy and top oil producer.
Trade Minister Olusegun Aganga was said to have made his
interest in the job known when he chaired the WTO's ministerial
conference last December, but several trade officials said
Finance Minister Ngozi Okonjo-Iweala, who missed out on the top
job at the World Bank earlier this year, was now likely to be
"She seems to be pretty good, willing and available," said
Her office did not reply to a request for comment.
"I can't confirm this because the process has not started,"
said one Nigerian official.
NOT ANOTHER MINISTER
Kyerematen can expect to face at least one rival from Latin
America. The most talked about name in Geneva is Brazil's
much-admired Ambassador to the WTO Roberto Azevedo. He was on
holiday this week and not available to comment on any potential
bid but a Brazilian trade source said his government was aware
that he had been approached by different delegations in Geneva.
"As far as I understand they're thinking about it but
there's no decision about whether Brazil will submit a candidate
or not," the source said. "I don't think they're thinking about
Despite the high regard of his peers, Azevedo's weakness is
that he lacks the ministerial status widely seen as necessary to
succeed Lamy, a former European Union Trade Commissioner.
"At the end, if it was Tim versus Roberto, Tim would win,"
said one trade negotiator. But he said that many of his fellow
diplomats would prefer not to have an ex-minister in the job.
"They blame Lamy because he's tried to solve things at the
level of head of state or at least minister. He always calls
ministers and presidents and prime ministers and so forth and
people say that's why the (Doha) round has not succeeded."
THE SOLIDARITY MYTH
If Azevedo does enter the race, he may also feel the need to
tread carefully because Brazil is widely blamed for splitting
the Latin American support in 2005, when his predecessor Luiz
Felipe Seixas Correa ruined the chances of Uruguay's Carlos
Perez del Castillo, enabling Lamy to sprint through the middle.
No Latin American candidate has yet emerged. One that many
trade diplomats long to see enter the contest is former Mexican
President Ernesto Zedillo. But he declined to enter the last WTO
race and is now at Yale University in the United States.
"I can tell you he would not be interested in being Director
General of the World Trade Organization," one Latin American
Any Mexican candidate would be handicapped because another
Mexican, Angel Gurria, already heads the OECD, and leading both
bodies would widely be seen as wielding too much influence.
Zedillo may also be embroiled in a court case in
Connecticut, where 10 Mexican Indians are seeking $50 million
and a declaration of guilt against him for alleged war crimes,
the Economist magazine reported this week.
Costa Rica's Trade Minister Anabel Gonzalez is also a
potential candidate who campaigned to succeed Lamy at the WTO's
December meeting, sources said.
She knows the WTO well, having headed the agriculture
division in the WTO bureaucracy, but her tenure was divisive due
to personal tensions between Pascal Lamy and Crawford Falconer,
former chair of the Doha round agriculture negotiations.
Much rests on the ability of developing countries to unite
behind one candidate, having failed to do so last time and
subsequently watched Nigeria and Colombian candidates lose the
top job at the World Bank to Korean-born American Jim Yong Kim.
"This developing country solidarity thing is very often a
myth," said one source. "There's a concern that one might
balance the other one out. This all starts to push the whole
thing in the direction of Groser."