March 28, 2011 / 8:56 AM / 7 years ago

India, Pakistan talk in shadow of "cricket diplomacy"

NEW DELHI (Reuters) - Indian and Pakistani officials began their first formal peace talks since the 2008 Mumbai attacks on Monday in a meeting pushed into the background by the decision of their leaders to meet during a World Cup cricket match between the two countries.

India's home secretary G. K. Pillai (R) shakes hands with his Pakistani counterpart Chaudhary Qamar Zaman before the start of the Indo-Pak secretary level talks in New Delhi March 28, 2011. REUTERS/B Mathur

The two home secretaries, the top civil servants in charge of security issues, met in New Delhi to repair relations between nuclear rivals broken off the attacks, when Pakistani militants killed 166 people in a three-day shooting spree in India’s financial capital.

The talks are due to end on Tuesday, but the focus has already turned to Wednesday’s World Cup cricket semi-final between the two old rivals after Prime Minister Manmohan Singh invited Pakistani Prime Minister Yusuf Raza Gilani to the game.

“Talks are extremely positive and in the right direction,” Home Secretary Gopal Pillai told reporters at the end of the first day of talks. The two sides would issue a joint statement on Tuesday afternoon, he added.

Progress in Monday’s talks was anyway expected to be small. They are about preparing the groundwork for a ministerial meeting in July that would put issues like Kashmir, terrorism and trade on the negotiating table in what is known as the “composite dialogue”.

The two countries, which have fought three wars since their independence from British rule in 1947, agreed in February to resume formal peace talks.

In a goodwill gesture ahead of the cricket match, President Asif Ali Zardari will also free an Indian national, Gopal Das, who has been languishing in a Pakistani prison for 27 years as an alleged spy.

Wednesday’s match has been heralded as “cricket diplomacy”, something of a tradition between the two countries that has at least helped ease tensions in the past.

Former Pakistani president Mohammed Zia ul-Haq visited India in 1987 to watch a one-day match when the two countries’ armies were eyeball-to-eyeball on the border.

In 2005, Pakistan’s then military ruler, Pervez Musharraf, travelled to India to watch a match but the trip effectively turned into a summit and the two leaders agreed to open up the militarised frontier dividing the disputed Kashmir region.

“Going by past experience, however, cricket diplomacy has sadly been about short-lived atmospherics,” The Times of India said in an editorial.

The match has turned Chandigarh into a fortress. There will be a “no fly zone” around the stadium and commandos will patrol the city. Anti-aircraft guns will be placed near the stadium, the Times of India reported.

Touted as “the mother of all cricket contests”, the game between the two cricket-mad nations has reportedly seen requests from business tycoons, including India’s richest man, Mukesh Ambani, to allow them to park their private jets in Chandigarh.

Tickets sell on the black market for as much as $2,000 in a country where 450 million live on less than $1.25 a day.

On Monday, an estimated 1,000 angry protesters hurled stones and clashed with police outside the stadium in the tiny town of Mohali, but police said the protests were not connected with a shortage of tickets that has angered fans in several other Indian cities.

The match is taken so seriously and the stakes for national honour so high that Pakistani Interior Minister Rehman Malik warned the Pakistan team not to cheat, refocusing attention on match-fixing allegations last year that embarrassed the country and tarnished its cricket reputation internationally.

“I had issued a warning yesterday that there should not be any match-fixing. This time I have very close eye on it and if any such thing happens, we will take action,” he said.

He said players had been put under strict intelligence surveillance and their movements and telephone calls were being monitored. “Because what has happened in London, we cannot take a chance.”

Three team members were given lengthy suspensions by the International Cricket Council following last year’s allegations of spot-fixing during a tour of England.


Pakistanis will be sceptical that Singh is simply playing to his domestic audience and trying to distract from a string of corruption scandals that have effectively paralysed the Congress-led government for months.

“If the Indians have invited the prime minister and the president, there is no harm in going there, because this is a gesture,” said Ejaz Haider, a Pakistani political analyst and contributing editor for Friday Times.

“But this gesture in itself is not going to result in any breakthrough in substantial terms.”

Many Pakistanis also see little chance the ruling Congress party and its powerful, ruler-behind-the-scenes Sonia Gandhi are really interested in making peace overtures.

It is a risky issue for any Indian leader, one that wins few votes and would quickly backfire if there was another attack in India blamed on Pakistan.

India, for its part, has always been sceptical about peace talks with civilian leaders in Pakistan, who play second fiddle to a more hawkish military intelligence service and army.


But there may be new political winds blowing.

The 78-year-old Singh was born in what is now Pakistan before moving to India after Partition in 1947. Peace with Pakistan would secure his political legacy, threatened by months of corruption scams that have led the opposition to call for his resignation.

Pakistan is also facing an increasingly difficult regional environment. India’s new economic clout has seen it grow in influence with Pakistan’s traditional ally, the United States. New Delhi has also been increasingly involved in aid to Afghanistan, seen as Islamabad’s backyard.

In one sign that India may be taking these talks more seriously, the Times of India reported on Sunday that New Delhi wanted to open channels of communications with the Pakistan army chief and the head of its intelligence service, seen as the real powerbrokers in any talks.

Singh’s perceived determination may win similar commitment from the other side.

“This kind of reputation that the PM has, in my view it helps,” said Naresh Chandra, a former Indian ambassador to the United States.

“It creates a climate that you can do business with this prime minister. It encourages the Pakistani side to do so.”

Additional reporting by C.J. Kuncheria and Nigam Prusty in NEW DELHI and Augustine Anthony and Kamran Haider in ISLAMABAD; Editing by Alex Richardson

Our Standards:The Thomson Reuters Trust Principles.
0 : 0
  • narrow-browser-and-phone
  • medium-browser-and-portrait-tablet
  • landscape-tablet
  • medium-wide-browser
  • wide-browser-and-larger
  • medium-browser-and-landscape-tablet
  • medium-wide-browser-and-larger
  • above-phone
  • portrait-tablet-and-above
  • above-portrait-tablet
  • landscape-tablet-and-above
  • landscape-tablet-and-medium-wide-browser
  • portrait-tablet-and-below
  • landscape-tablet-and-below