NEW YORK (Reuters Breakingviews) - Infowars came to my hometown three years ago. Dan Bidondi, who identified himself as a reporter for the website that hawks extremist views and fake news, arrived with a video camera at the municipal center of Newtown, Connecticut, to cover a routine Board of Education meeting. Bidondi wasn’t interested in hearing how a New England hamlet of 27,000 was dealing with bus schedules or budget priorities.
Instead, he was there to give a man from Florida a platform upon which to express his delirious beliefs. Wolfgang Halbig and a bevy of followers, including a man clad in 18th-century patriot garb, showed up to bully community leaders into proving the 2012 shooting at Sandy Hook Elementary School actually occurred. Halbig had developed a following with calls to exhume the bodies of the 20 first-graders killed that day and release police photographs of the grisly crime scene.
On Sunday, Comcast’s flagship network, NBC, will extend a similar courtesy to Infowars by airing a segment on Alex Jones, its founder and conspiracy theorist-in-chief. Megyn Kelly, the former Fox News anchor whom President Donald Trump accused of bleeding “from her wherever” when she challenged him during an election debate, interviewed Jones for her new prime-time program. It competes with CBS’s vaunted, long-running newsmagazine “60 Minutes.”
The decision unleashed a well-deserved backlash against NBC. Viewers are calling for boycotts. Petitions crawl across Facebook and Twitter demanding NBC withdraw the piece. JPMorgan Chase temporarily pulled advertisements, and others may follow. The furor forced Kelly to withdraw from a fundraiser on Wednesday for a charity led by parents who lost children at Sandy Hook, and one which I helped to found.
Just a few weeks into her tenure, Kelly – who had been offered $20 million to stay at Fox News, according to media reports – has put NBC, a business that generates $10 billion a year in revenue, into a pickle that could have commercial ramifications for its parent company. If the broadcaster forges ahead with a segment that serves to legitimize Jones, Infowars and the falsifications they peddle, sponsors may further withdraw their custom as more affluent and educated viewers flee.
As Uber and other companies have learned, uprisings can mushroom quickly in the social-media age. In the short term, that would make Kelly’s much-ballyhooed show a casualty, just as it did her former Fox News colleague Bill O‘Reilly, who was pushed out earlier this year following an advertiser uprising over a sexual-harassment scandal that enveloped him.
There’s a bigger risk from Kelly’s embrace of Jones for the $200 billion cable operator controlled and run by family scion Brian Roberts. The willingness to elevate a bonkers theory that Sandy Hook and other tragedies either didn’t happen or was an elaborate hoax perpetrated by shadowy government actors to deprive Americans of their freedoms creates a false equivalency that threatens the mission at NBC, home to hit shows such as “Blindspot,” “This Is Us” and “The Tonight Show with Jimmy Fallon.”
The network launched by David Sarnoff at the 1939 World’s Fair in Queens prides itself as “a company uniquely positioned to inform, empower and inspire, we embrace the opportunity to create conversation and mobilize action to address some of the world’s most critical issues.”
To remain true to those values, Kelly and NBC really have but one option: the show must go on, and it must expose the real danger of the fake news Jones and his ilk pose not just to NBC's mission but to the wider American social fabric. She can start by revisiting video (here) from the Newtown Board of Education, where she will see Halbig and a procession of other adherents to Jones' conspiracies disrupting the normal course of business in a town traumatized by tragedy.
To pull the broadcast would be far too damaging. It would suggest either a lack of editorial independence at NBC, or a failure to produce good work by Kelly – or perhaps both. Worse still, it would allow Jones to cry censorship by what he calls the “dying dinosaur media systems of information suppression.” That would only validate the warped worldview of his audience, and maybe even grow their numbers.
Since releasing a trailer and a smiling selfie with Jones, Kelly and her producers have been scrambling to make their piece more critical of Jones and Infowars. In a series of phone calls on Wednesday evening, Kelly reached out to a handful of Sandy Hook parents. They repeated their demands that NBC not broadcast the interview, and declined to participate on camera.
Jones, perhaps sensing both opportunity and risk, released a video on Thursday night including audio recordings in which he claims Kelly can be heard promising him a fair shot: “It’s not gonna be some gotcha hit piece.” Kelly and NBC News face an extremely high bar, with potential implications for the company’s income statement. They can’t withdraw and they can’t produce a puff piece. If they fail to expose Jones’ cruelty to the truth, they devalue the network.
There is a solution, albeit not a flashy one. NBC could run the video from when Infowars visited Newtown. It shows Halbig and the “patriot,” who identified himself as Melbourne Sann of Rome, New York, interrupting a meeting of unpaid volunteers, Republicans mostly and some Democrats, doing their best to provide a good education for children, some of whom were in the school when a gunman killed their peers and six of their teachers.
As they’ll see, Halbig isn’t particularly rude. Sann, who operates a daycare center in his town, is polite, too. And yet they embrace a fiction that Jones pioneered and parlayed into notoriety, a nod from Trump and White House press credentials for Infowars. That is what makes him so dangerous to the country, and perhaps even to Comcast’s bottom line.
Reuters Breakingviews is the world's leading source of agenda-setting financial insight. As the Reuters brand for financial commentary, we dissect the big business and economic stories as they break around the world every day. A global team of about 30 correspondents in New York, London, Hong Kong and other major cities provides expert analysis in real time.
Sign up for a free trial of our full service at https://www.breakingviews.com/trial and follow us on Twitter @Breakingviews and at www.breakingviews.com. All opinions expressed are those of the authors.