Oil below $100 highlights widening gap in OPEC pain thresholds

LONDON, June 25 Tue Jun 25, 2013 7:39pm IST

Coal Mining In The Punjab

Coal Mining In The Punjab

In Choa Saidan Shah miners dig coal with crude pick axes and load it onto donkeys to be transported to the surface earning a team of 4 workers around $10 to be split between them.  Slideshow 

LONDON, June 25 (Reuters) - Oil's fall below the $100 a barrel favoured by OPEC exposes the deepening divide between countries in the group better able to cope with a lower price and those most hurt by it, making collective action to halt any further price slide harder.

The price of oil dropped below $100 this week from a 2013 high of $119.17 in February, pressured by lacklustre demand and ample supply. While a sustained sub-$100 Brent is bearable for Saudi Arabia, it puts a strain on others such as Iran.

There is no immediate prospect of the Organization of the Petroleum Exporting Countries cutting supply to boost the price, not least because top producer Saudi Arabia - which would lead any cutback - has financial reserves that will help it endure oil at $80 or $90.

"Oil at $80 would cause concern with OPEC members outside the Gulf," said a senior OPEC delegate who requested anonymity. "But there won't be a quick response from Gulf producers who have built up surplus financial reserves over the past few years."

Others including Iran, Venezuela and Algeria need far higher prices to make their budget targets, and are least able to offer output cuts. The widening division over members' breakeven oil prices will make a coordinated response harder.

"To have some OPEC discipline is going to be very difficult because everybody for now will want Saudi Arabia to do the job (of cutting production) by itself," said Olivier Jakob of consultants Petromatrix in Zug, Switzerland.

"And if Saudi Arabia does not want to do the job alone, then it needs to let the price drop to force the others to also come in."

OPEC last took united action to prop up prices in 2008 during the financial crisis. Some oil market forecasts indicate that rising supplies of U.S. shale will reduce demand for OPEC oil which could mean cuts are needed down the road.

To an extent, all 12 OPEC members need a robust oil price as crude oil is a major source of government revenue. High production and high prices saw the group that pumps a third of the world's oil record revenue of $1 trillion last year.

Exporters are generally coming to rely on higher prices per barrel to counter pressures including rising populations, stagnant oil output, increased social spending to head off Arab Spring-type protests and infrastructure investment.

But the oil price below which an exporting country faces trouble differs widely based both on its budget commitments and the cost of oil production.

Saudi Arabia and fellow Arab Gulf producers Kuwait, the United Arab Emirates and Qatar have greater capacity to handle lower prices. Estimates for Saudi Arabia's breakeven price vary from $85 to $95, depending on projections for its spending.

After pumping 10 million bpd with oil at $110 last year and 9 million barrels per day (bpd) with oil at above $100 this year, Saudi Arabia has built up formidable financial reserves, estimated at over $650 billion.

OPEC met last month and agreed to retain its official 30 million bpd production for the rest of the year - making it unlikely the group will make any formal adjustment to supply.

If the time comes for OPEC to scale back production, Riyadh is likely to seek assistance from other members - primarily Iraq, which has ramped up its output in recent years.

According to an analysis by Petroleum Finance Co., Saudi Arabia and Iraq need similar prices in order for their current accounts to break even. But Saudi would be better able to withstand a drop due to its foreign exchange reserves and ability to borrow.

Iran is the most at risk as its crude oil exports have more than halved over the past 18 months to around 1 million bpd due to U.S. and European sanctions over its nuclear work.

Tehran needs an oil price of $140 in 2013 to balance the books, according to the International Monetary Fund, the highest among the OPEC members it provided figures for and much higher than $84.50 for Saudi Arabia.

"Iran's domestic budget is almost out of control and the cost of doing business with the outside world is rising," said Mehdi Varzi, a former Iranian oil official who now runs an energy consultancy in the UK.

"It's very expensive to run the economy and the squeeze will get worse." (Editing by Peter Graff)

Comments (0)
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.

  • Most Popular
  • Most Shared

Diplomacy

REUTERS SHOWCASE

Maruti Results

Maruti Results

Maruti Suzuki says profits helped by sentiment, not growth.  Full Article 

Tracking the Monsoon

Tracking the Monsoon

Monsoon turns patchy after revival.  Full Article 

ICICI Profit Up

ICICI Profit Up

ICICI Bank Q1 net profit up 17 percent, beats estimates.  Full Article 

Pharma Sector

Pharma Sector

FDA raises concern over drug production process at Cadila  Full Article 

Coal India

Coal India

Some Coal India mines may be run by foreign firms - minister  Full Article 

Fuel Prices

Fuel Prices

IOC to cut petrol prices by 1.5 pct from Friday  Read 

Economic Pulse

Economic Pulse

India's infrastructure output growth hits 9-month high in June  Full Article | Related Story 

Joint Bid

Joint Bid

ONGC, Oil India bid $1.5 bln for stake in Murphy Oil's Malaysia assets - sources  Full Article 

Reuters India Mobile

Reuters India Mobile

Get the latest news on the go. Visit Reuters India on your mobile device.  Full Coverage