Do More With Reuters
Partner Services

Court rules Sarkozy voodoo doll can remain on sale

Fri Nov 28, 2008 9:41pm IST
 
Email | Print | | Single Page
[-] Text [+]

PARIS (Reuters) - A doll representing French President Nicolas Sarkozy and an accompanying "voodoo manual" with directions for sticking pins into the figurine can remain on sale after a ruling from an appeals court on Friday.

The doll, which has been on sale since Oct. 9, is adorned with a choice of Sarkozy's best-known remarks including his now-famous admonition to a heckler, "Get lost you pathetic arsehole!". It also comes with pins and a set of instructions for sticking them into the doll.

The court ruled that the doll and the accompanying volume entitled "Nicolas Sarkozy, the voodoo manual" constituted an "offence against the personal dignity" of Sarkozy.

But it said it would be "disproportionate and harmful to liberty of expression" to ban their sale outright.

Instead, it said that the doll may be sold provided it carries a notice of the judgment attached.

It also ordered the manufacturers to pay Sarkozy 2,000 euros ($2,588) in costs, all other costs of the case as well as a symbolic one euro in damages.

Sarkozy's lawyer Thierry Herzog said he was satisfied by the judgment. "The important thing is that consistent principles and jurisprudence should be applied," he said.

A lower court last month rejected an application by Sarkozy to prevent the publishers from selling the doll and the manual, ruling that the items were "within the authorised boundaries of freedom of expression and the right to humour".

Voodoo is a religion practised in some parts of the Caribbean and the southern United States.

According to a common belief, practitioners stick pins into dolls representing their enemies to harm them. Specialists in voodoo say they do not use dolls in this way.

REUTERS WEEKEND

Glory for Big B

Lifetime award for Bollywood actor Amitabh Bachchan.  Video 

'Trashy' Affair

Beijing man turns unwanted plastic bags into kites.  Video 

 
The new Droid phone, a Motorola Inc. and Verizon Wireless phone based on Google Inc's Android 2.0 system, is shown at a media event in New York October 28, 2009.REUTERS/Brendan McDermid
Motorola Droid

Not the Droid you’re looking for?  Blog 

View of the Casa Poporului or House of the People, now the Parliament Palace, in downtown Bucharest November 6, 2009.  REUTERS/Bogdan Cristel
Travel Postcard

48 hours in Bucharest for architecture buffs.  Full Article 

 
Russian Finance Minister Alexey Kudrin poses with his G20 colleagues and central bank leaders during the family photo at the G20 Finance Ministers meeting at a hotel in St. Andrews, Scotland. REUTERS/POOL New
Pledge to support economies

G20 financial leaders pledged to prepare strategies to end emergency support for their economies, but to keep the aid flowing until recovery was assured.  Full Article | Related Story 

Photo
Miss England gives up crown over brawl reports Friday, 6 Nov 2009 

LONDON (Reuters) - Beauty pageant winner Miss England gave up her title on Friday after reports she had been involved in a nightclub brawl with another beauty queen.  Full Article